West Babylon Real Estate & Local Guide

West Babylon, NY Real Estate & Local Guide

West Babylon is the most populous hamlet in the Town of Babylon: about 43,000 people between Lindenhurst and the Village of Babylon, stretching from Route 109 down to three necks of land on the Great South Bay.

West Babylon is an unincorporated hamlet in the Town of Babylon, Suffolk County, so local government is the Town and the County, not a village. It borders Lindenhurst and North Lindenhurst to the west, East Farmingdale and Wyandanch to the north, Deer Park to the northeast, North Babylon and the Village of Babylon to the east, and the Great South Bay to the south. It has no LIRR station of its own; the Lindenhurst and Babylon stations sit on either side.

View Homes for Sale

Jump to: Quick Facts · How West Babylon Came to Be · Waterfront & Venetian Shores · Parks · Shopping & Dining · Getting Around · Schools · FAQs

West Babylon at a Glance

  • Government: Unincorporated hamlet in the Town of Babylon, Suffolk County.
  • Population: About 43,200 (2020 census), the largest hamlet in the Town of Babylon.
  • ZIP codes: 11704, plus 11707. Some homes inside the hamlet use the Babylon or Lindenhurst post office, and some homes outside it use a West Babylon address. A ZIP code doesn't tell you the hamlet, the school district or the fire district.
  • Train: No station in the hamlet. The nearest LIRR stops are Lindenhurst and Babylon on the Babylon Branch.
  • Main roads: Sunrise Highway and Montauk Highway east-west, with Route 109, Great East Neck Road and Little East Neck Road running north-south.
  • Schools: West Babylon UFSD covers about half the hamlet. Other sections are in the Lindenhurst, Babylon, North Babylon or Wyandanch districts.
  • Library: West Babylon Public Library, 211 Route 109.

How West Babylon Came to Be

Where "Babylon" Comes From

The earliest written record of the name "Babylon" is tied to Nathaniel Conklin's house, built in 1803 on Deer Park Avenue. His mother, Phebe Smith Conklin, is traditionally credited with choosing the name. In 1830 the local post office was renamed from Huntington South to Babylon, and in 1872 the Town of Babylon split off from the Town of Huntington.

From "the West End of Babylon" to Its Own Name

For most of the 1800s, the whole area that's now West Babylon, North Babylon and the Village of Babylon was just "Babylon." "West Babylon" started as a direction, the western side of town. When the Village of Babylon incorporated in 1893, a line was drawn, but West Babylon didn't really get its own identity until the building boom after World War II. Residents pushed for their own address in 1951, the West Babylon post office opened on Sunrise Highway in 1956, and it got the 11704 ZIP code in 1963.

Walt Whitman, a Ballpark and a Windmill

  • Walt Whitman taught here. The area's first school stood near Montauk Highway and Great East Neck Road, and the poet taught there in the mid-1830s while his family farmed nearby, on land that's now part of the Great South Bay Shopping Center.
  • Belmont Junction. Around 1874, a rail junction here linked a branch line to the Long Island Rail Road. It served as a freight and telegraph stop, and later as a trolley stop. From about 1910 to 1920, a trolley ran through the area between Amityville and Babylon.
  • Barton's Stadium. Actor James Barton opened it in 1936 as the first lighted sports park in Suffolk County. The site is now Santapogue Elementary School, which opened in 1952.
  • The Bulk's Nursery windmill. Built along Montauk Highway in 1930, it became a local landmark, and people remembered it long after it came down in the 1980s.

The Post-War Boom

West Babylon went from about 2,700 people in 1950 to about 8,000 in 1960, and kept growing to more than 43,000. The Great South Bay Shopping Center opened in 1956, the fire department organized in 1945 and became its own fire district in 1948, and the West Babylon Public Library opened in 1983.

What Is Your West Babylon Home Worth?

Thinking about selling, or just curious? Get a free home value for your West Babylon home.

Get My Free West Babylon Home Value

The Waterfront & Venetian Shores

South of Montauk Highway, West Babylon runs down to the Great South Bay on Santapogue Neck, Great East Neck and part of Little East Neck, with canals cutting in from the bay.

Venetian Shores

On the southwest corner of the hamlet, Venetian Shores was laid out as a bayfront development starting in 1926. It's part of West Babylon, but its homes use the Lindenhurst post office, school district, library and fire department. That's why you'll see it listed with a Lindenhurst address. More on that side of the line in my Lindenhurst guide.

If you're buying on the water, check the flood zone, elevation certificate, flood insurance cost, bulkhead condition and dock rights for that specific property. Never assume boat access from a canal view.

Parks & Getting Outside

The Town of Babylon lists these parks in West Babylon:

Venetian Shores Beach & Spray Park

On Granada Parkway, the Town's Venetian Shores Park has a bay beach with swimming, a boat launch ramp, fishing, softball and turf fields, basketball and tennis courts, a roller hockey rink, a playground and a spray park. The beach and spray park are for Town of Babylon residents with a permit, open daily from late June through Labor Day.

Anthony Sanchez Memorial Park & Pool

At Sawyer Avenue and Bedell Road: baseball and softball fields, basketball and tennis courts, a playground, a picnic area and a Town pool with a children's pool. Check the Town's pool page for season and permit details.

Neighborhood Parks

  • Van Bourgondien Park, Albin Avenue: soccer fields, tennis courts and a playground.
  • Capt. John C. Pape Memorial Park, Old Farmingdale Road: football and junior baseball fields and a playground.
  • Scott Park, Junction Avenue and 3rd Street: basketball courts and a playground.

Shopping & Dining

West Babylon is where a lot of this stretch of the South Shore does its shopping. The Great South Bay Shopping Center on Montauk Highway has been there since 1956. There's no single downtown here. Instead, the restaurants sit along the main roads: Route 109, Montauk Highway and Sunrise Highway, plus the neighborhood pizzerias up the East Neck roads and a couple of spots on the water at Bergen Point. Here's the lineup by road. Hours change, so check before you go.

Route 109

  • Gino's Pizza of West Babylon, 90 Route 109. A family-owned pizzeria and restaurant since 1965.
  • Kumo, 76 Route 109. All-you-can-eat sushi and Asian fusion.
  • 109 Thaiana, 130–132 Route 109. Thai and Asian fusion. Closed Mondays.
  • Alfredo's Pizza, 134 Route 109. A family-run pizzeria serving the area since 1999.

Montauk Highway

  • The Bagel Factory, 615 West Montauk Highway. Hand-rolled bagels, open every day from 5 a.m.
  • Izumi, 527 Montauk Highway. Sushi and hibachi.
  • Mushroom, 779 Montauk Highway. Chinese and Japanese, dine-in and take-out.
  • Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant, 999 West Montauk Highway. A family-owned Italian restaurant for more than 35 years.

Sunrise Highway

  • Cafe Gio, 761 Sunrise Highway. A family-owned Italian restaurant with a full bar, open since 1994.
  • Red Zone Bar & Grill, 770 Sunrise Highway. Wings, burgers and a full bar.
  • AMF Babylon Lanes, 430 Sunrise Highway. 56 lanes, plus a sports bar, an arcade and billiards. A good rainy-day stop.

Up the East Neck Roads

The neighborhood pizzerias, each one somebody's go-to:

  • Albert's Pizza, 419 Great East Neck Road. A longtime West Babylon pizzeria, with heroes, pasta and catering.
  • Brunello's, 929 Little East Neck Road. A family-run pizzeria and restaurant, open daily.
  • Giovanni's Pizza, 1009 Little East Neck Road. Sicilian and New York-style pies. Closed Mondays.
  • Miceli Brothers, 1030 Little East Neck Road. A pizzeria and restaurant with party rooms.

On the Water at Bergen Point

  • VERN Restaurant & Bar, 301 Bergen Avenue. Caribbean-style seafood and drinks with water views, open Wednesday through Sunday.
  • Gemelli's at Bergen Point, 69 Bergen Avenue. The catering hall at the Bergen Point golf course, with a sports bar that's open year-round.

Diners, Delis & Comfort Food

Got a West Babylon spot that belongs on this list? Tell me.

Getting Around

By train: West Babylon doesn't have its own station. Most of the hamlet is a short drive from either Lindenhurst station or Babylon station on the Babylon Branch. Check the MTA's station information for parking and schedules at each.

By car: Sunrise Highway and Montauk Highway run east-west through the hamlet. Route 109 crosses the northern side, and Great East Neck Road and Little East Neck Road run north-south down toward the bay.

Schools: Know Your District

West Babylon is one of the clearest examples of why a mailing address doesn't tell you the school district.

West Babylon Union Free School District

The West Babylon UFSD serves about half the hamlet, plus parts of the Village of Babylon and Wyandanch. Its schools are John F. Kennedy, Santapogue, South Bay and Tooker Avenue Elementary Schools, West Babylon Junior High School and West Babylon Senior High School. The district office is at 10 Farmingdale Road.

Other Districts in West Babylon

  • Lindenhurst UFSD serves Venetian Shores.
  • Babylon UFSD serves the area around Sawyer Avenue Park.
  • North Babylon UFSD serves an eastern section bounded by Belmont Avenue, Montgomery Avenue, Little East Neck Road and Straight Path.
  • Wyandanch UFSD serves a small area around Cumberbach Street.

Verify the district for the individual property. Search: homes in the West Babylon school district.

Buying in West Babylon?

From the canals off the bay to the blocks up by Route 109, browse everything listed in West Babylon now, with every filter.

West Babylon Homes for Sale

What's My West Babylon Home Worth?

It starts with one step. Get a free home value estimate, and if you want an exact number, I'll follow up with a personal analysis.

Get My West Babylon Home Value

Selling a Home in West Babylon

Price it right, fix what an inspector will flag before you list, and present it well from day one. Know your school district and have it ready for buyers, because in West Babylon it's one of the first questions. If your home is on the water, have your flood and elevation paperwork ready too. Reach out to me directly and we'll put together the right plan.

West Babylon Resource Directory

West Babylon FAQs

Is West Babylon a village?

No. West Babylon is an unincorporated hamlet governed by the Town of Babylon and Suffolk County. It's separate from the incorporated Village of Babylon to the east.

How did West Babylon get its name?

It started as a description of the western part of Babylon. The whole area was called Babylon through the 1800s, and West Babylon got its own identity after World War II, including its own post office in 1956.

What school district is West Babylon in?

About half the hamlet is in the West Babylon Union Free School District. Other sections are in the Lindenhurst, Babylon, North Babylon or Wyandanch districts. Verify the district for any specific property.

Does West Babylon have a train station?

No. The nearest LIRR stations are Lindenhurst and Babylon, both on the Babylon Branch.

Is Venetian Shores in West Babylon or Lindenhurst?

Venetian Shores is in the hamlet of West Babylon, but its homes use the Lindenhurst post office, school district, library and fire department. It is not part of the Village of Lindenhurst.

How do I find out what my West Babylon home is worth?

Start with a free home value estimate, and I'll follow up with a personal analysis of your home.

What Should I Add to My West Babylon Guide?

From the bay necks to Route 109, West Babylon is a big place with a lot of history most people don't know, like Walt Whitman teaching at its first schoolhouse. If there's a restaurant, park, event or piece of local history I'm missing, tell me.

Tell Me What I Should Add

I'm John Cordeira, Broker/Owner of Cordeira Homes. I live a few towns west in Massapequa Park and have sold Long Island homes for more than 20 years.

John Cordeira | Cordeira Homes | #RippedRealtor

Current Homes for Sale in West Babylon

Browse the newest West Babylon listings below. For every filter, use the full live search for West Babylon homes for sale.

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!