Massapequa Shores Real Estate in Massapequa, NY

Massapequa Shores is an established South Shore subcommunity in Massapequa with a mix of waterfront and non-waterfront homes, residential canals and easy access to the broader Massapequa community.

The neighborhood includes traditional single-family homes, renovated properties and waterfront homes where buyers may encounter docks, bulkheads, canal views and boating access.

It is also close to some of the places that have become part of the Massapequa identity — including longtime local restaurants and one of Long Island's most recognizable hamburger stands.

I’m John Cordeira, Broker/Owner of Cordeira Homes, and I’ve been helping Long Island buyers and sellers for more than 20 years. This page is my main Massapequa Shores neighborhood resource, with current listings below and links into my broader Massapequa real estate and local guides.

View Current Massapequa Shores Homes

About Massapequa Shores

Massapequa Shores is located in the southern portion of Massapequa near the Great South Bay and the network of residential canals that helps define this part of Long Island's South Shore.

The community includes both waterfront and interior residential properties, so buyers should evaluate the individual street, lot and house rather than assuming every Massapequa Shores property offers the same waterfront access or amenities.

A home only a few blocks inland can have a very different market profile from one sitting directly on a canal or bayfront location.

Waterfront Homes in Massapequa Shores

Waterfront real estate is an important part of Massapequa Shores, but not every home in the neighborhood is directly on the water.

Depending on the individual property, waterfront buyers may encounter:

  • Canal frontage
  • Bayfront or broader water views
  • Private docks
  • Boat lifts
  • Bulkheads
  • Outdoor entertaining areas
  • Direct boating access

Those characteristics can vary significantly even between nearby properties.

If you're comparing the different waterfront sections of the area, visit my Massapequa Waterfront Homes guide.

Private Beach and Association Rights

One detail buyers should pay close attention to in Massapequa Shores is whether a particular property includes private beach or association rights.

Those rights should never be assumed simply because a home is located in Massapequa Shores.

Town of Oyster Bay records reference the Jomarr Beach Club Homeowners Association within the Massapequa Shores area.

View Town of Oyster Bay Records Referencing Jomarr Beach Club →

If a listing advertises private beach, association or deeded access, buyers should verify the specific rights through the deed, title report, association documents and their attorney before relying on that amenity as part of the purchase.

Boating From Massapequa Shores

For some buyers, the ability to keep a boat behind the house is one of the biggest reasons to consider Massapequa Shores.

But waterfront does not automatically mean that every property will accommodate every boat.

Buyers may want to investigate:

  • Water depth
  • Tidal conditions
  • Canal width
  • Dock dimensions
  • Boat-lift configuration
  • Bulkhead condition
  • Access toward the Great South Bay
  • Existing permits and approvals

The waterfront should be evaluated as carefully as the house itself.

Bulkheads, Docks and Waterfront Improvements

Bulkheads and docks can represent an important part of both the usefulness and future maintenance cost of a waterfront property.

When evaluating a Massapequa Shores waterfront home, buyers may want to understand:

  • The age and construction of the bulkhead
  • Repair and maintenance history
  • Dock configuration
  • Boat-lift condition
  • Water frontage
  • Permits and approvals for existing improvements

These details can make two otherwise similar waterfront homes very different from one another.

Flood Information in Massapequa Shores

Because portions of Massapequa Shores are located along canals and near the Great South Bay, buyers should research flood information for the individual address.

The official FEMA Flood Map Service Center allows buyers and homeowners to research current federal flood hazard information by property location.

Check a Massapequa Shores Property on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center →

Flood-zone designation is only one part of the picture. Buyers should also speak with their lender, insurance professional, attorney and other appropriate specialists regarding the specific property.

Dining & Local Favorites Near Massapequa Shores

Massapequa Shores is primarily residential, but residents are only minutes from some of Massapequa's best-known local food spots.

All American Hamburger Drive-In

One of the most recognizable is All American Hamburger Drive-In at 4286 Merrick Road.

All American has been serving Massapequa since 1963 and has become a longtime Long Island tradition for burgers, fries, shakes and classic drive-in food.

The business describes itself as Long Island's only drive-in hamburger stand, and generations of local residents have made a stop at All American part of the Massapequa experience.

Its sister business, Marshall's Ice Cream Bar, is located directly next door, making burgers followed by ice cream a familiar local combination.

Smuggler Jack's

Smuggler Jack's at 157 Forest Avenue offers another very different type of local dining experience.

The restaurant sits along the waterfront and offers coastal-style dining, cocktails and views of the surrounding water — fitting naturally into the South Shore character of the area.

Tai Show Sushi

Tai Show Sushi at 4320 Merrick Road is another longtime local option close to Massapequa Shores.

The Japanese restaurant specializes in sushi and gives residents another established dining option right along the Merrick Road corridor.

These are only a few nearby examples. I'm also building a much broader Massapequa Shopping, Dining & Nightlife guide covering restaurants, bars, cafés and longtime local favorites throughout Massapequa and Massapequa Park.

Buying a Home in Massapequa Shores

When comparing Massapequa Shores properties, I would look beyond bedroom count and square footage.

Depending on your priorities, factors may include:

  • Location within Massapequa Shores
  • Waterfront versus interior location
  • Canal versus more open-water location
  • Lot size
  • Home size and layout
  • Renovations and overall condition
  • Dock and bulkhead condition, when applicable
  • Verified private beach or association rights
  • Flood considerations
  • Current competing inventory

You can also compare Massapequa Shores with current homes for sale throughout Massapequa.

What Is My Massapequa Shores Home Worth?

Home values in Massapequa Shores can vary considerably based on the house, lot, condition and location.

For waterfront homes, additional factors such as water frontage, canal or bay position, dock configuration, bulkhead condition and views can influence how one property compares with another.

Verified private beach or association rights may also distinguish one property from another.

If you own a Massapequa Shores home and want to understand its potential value, start with my Massapequa Home Value resource.

Get My Massapequa Shores Home Value

Selling a Home in Massapequa Shores

Marketing a Massapequa Shores home should clearly communicate the features that make the individual property different.

For an interior property, that may mean emphasizing:

  • Condition and renovations
  • Lot size
  • Layout
  • Location within the neighborhood
  • Any verified association or private-access rights

For waterfront property, the marketing should also clearly explain:

  • Water frontage
  • Dock configuration
  • Bulkhead condition
  • Canal or bay views
  • Boating access
  • Outdoor living areas

If you're considering selling, my Selling a Home in Massapequa guide covers pricing, preparation, marketing, offers and the overall selling process.

Massapequa Shores and the Massapequa Waterfront

Massapequa Shores is one of several distinct South Shore subcommunities buyers may compare when looking for waterfront property throughout the Massapequa area.

Start with my Massapequa Waterfront Homes hub.

You can also explore:

Explore More of Massapequa

Massapequa Shores is one part of the larger Massapequa community. I'm continuing to build local resources covering real estate, fitness, recreation, dining and everyday life throughout the area.

Frequently Asked Questions About Massapequa Shores

Is Massapequa Shores part of Massapequa?

Yes. Massapequa Shores is a residential subcommunity within Massapequa, New York.

Are all Massapequa Shores homes waterfront?

No. Massapequa Shores contains both waterfront and non-waterfront properties.

Does Massapequa Shores have canal and bayfront homes?

Yes. Buyers may encounter homes along residential canals as well as properties with broader water exposure or access toward the Great South Bay.

Can Massapequa Shores homes have private docks?

Yes. Some waterfront properties have docks, boat lifts, bulkheads or other boating improvements. The exact setup should be verified for the individual property.

Do all Massapequa Shores homes have private beach rights?

No. Private beach or association rights can be tied to specific properties and should never be assumed based solely on the neighborhood.

Buyers should verify any advertised rights through the deed, title report and applicable association documentation.

What is a famous place to eat near Massapequa Shores?

All American Hamburger Drive-In on Merrick Road has been serving Massapequa since 1963 and is one of the area's most recognizable longtime food landmarks.

Where can I compare Massapequa Shores with other waterfront communities?

Visit my Massapequa Waterfront Homes guide to compare Massapequa Shores with Biltmore Shores, Harbour Green, Old Harbour Green, Nassau Shores and nearby Bar Harbour.

How can I find out what my Massapequa Shores home is worth?

A useful valuation should consider appropriate comparable sales along with the home's location, lot, condition, waterfront characteristics and any verified private-access rights.

Start with my Massapequa Home Value resource.

Thinking About Buying or Selling in Massapequa Shores?

If you're considering a Massapequa Shores property, I can help you compare the home, its location within the neighborhood and — when applicable — waterfront, boating and private-access features.

Ask John About Massapequa Shores

Know Something About Massapequa Shores I Should Add?

I want this page to reflect the things that actually matter to Massapequa Shores homeowners, buyers and residents.

If you live in Massapequa Shores and there is a neighborhood feature, waterfront detail, restaurant, local business or community resource I should include, let me know.

Tell Me About Massapequa Shores

John Cordeira
Broker/Owner, Cordeira Homes
#RippedRealtor

Current Homes for Sale in Massapequa Shores

Newest Listings in Massapequa Shores

50 Marie Place, Massapequa
$899,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1050363 MLS
South Shore living at its finest! Situated on a gorgeous block in Massapequa Shores, this stunning brick-front split offers deeded beach rights to Dolphin Beach and beautiful spaces for entertaining and everyday relaxation. A newer walkway & front stoop wide, double-width driveway, and Craftsman-style front door create a welcoming first impression. Step inside and take in the view! Soaring cathedral ceilings, hardwood floors, and an open-concept layout with uninterrupted sightlines from front to back create a bright, airy atmosphere. The spacious living room features a gas fireplace and custom built-ins, bringing warmth and character to this inviting gathering space. The updated kitchen pairs maple cabinetry and stainless steel appliances with a large island, custom pullouts, and two Lazy Susans, pantry & granite countertops. Skylights fill the space with natural light, while the expansive formal dining room features distinctive architectural cutouts and sliding doors that connect indoor living to the backyard. Outside, a serene, professionally landscaped yard and expansive paver patio provide a beautiful setting for summer gatherings, outdoor dining, or a quiet morning coffee. A separate den offers additional space to entertain or unwind, with comfortable separation from the main living areas. An architectural roof and Pella windows complete this beautifully maintained home. Enjoy the coastal charm of Massapequa Shores, where neighborhood strolls and time at Dolphin Beach are part of everyday life.

50 Marie Place, Massapequa

94 massapequa Avenue, Massapequa
$887,999
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1056286 MLS
South of Merrick road in Massapequa, with No flood insurance required! This beautifully renovated home has been thoughtfully upgraded from Cosmetic finishes to utilities and systems! The care, love and thought is strewn the details of this home! With an expansive drive way, and one car attached garage, and a private oasis for a yard you'll regret not seeing it sooner! Featuring an entry foyer, which leads you to a beautiful living room or dining area if you so choose, set in front a beautiful gas fireplace. With the open concept taking you either through beautiful French doors on to a beautiful covered deck with the potential for an out door kitchen leading to the perfectly manicured and private yard; or let the open concept and sprawling wood floors take you through the 2026 built kitchen, with an oversized apron-front farmhouse sink, a professional -style gas range, equipped with a wine bar and fridge, microwave draw, and expansive refrigerator and freezer. Set with beautiful quartz countertop , a stunning herringbone back splash , under cabinet lighting, with custom over sized in lay cabinetry and coffee bar, this kitchen has it all! down the hall you'll be surprised by generous sized bedrooms each with ensuite full bathrooms. This home offers a ton of functional closet space and storage through out. Next you follow the beautiful refinished hard wood floors up stairs to find 2 more over sized bedrooms, each with massive closets, and through the hall you'll find edition walk in closets abutting each other and a full bathroom equipped with a jacuzzi tub. The basement is a full unfinished basement with separate entrance! The systems and utilities upgrades include but aren't limited to a built in general generator! Additional highlights hardwood flooring, recessed lighting, and a covered outdoor patio overlooking a beautifully maintained extremely private backyard—ideal for relaxing, entertaining, or enjoying outdoor living throughout the seasons. Conveniently located near Florence beach, Tobay Beach , shopping, dining, parks, transportation, and all that Massapequa has to offer. This exceptional home combines modern upgrades, quality construction, and thoughtful design into a truly turnkey opportunity.

94 massapequa Avenue, Massapequa

12 Jetmore Place, Massapequa
$999,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1049641 MLS
Coastal living takes center stage at 12 Jetmore Place, where sun-filled interiors and tranquil canal views create an inviting waterfront retreat in Massapequa Shores. This thoughtfully designed 4 Bedroom, 2.5 Bath Colonial offers an airy, open living space made for both comfortable everyday living and entertaining. An inviting Foyer with french doors introduces the Living Room, where picture-frame molding and a stone wood-burning Fireplace add warmth and character. The open layout flows effortlessly into the expansive Kitchen and Dining Area, illuminated by three skylights and walls of windows overlooking the canal. A generous peninsula, double ovens, gas cooking and stainless-steel appliances make the Kitchen a natural gathering place, while radiant heat adds year-round comfort. Andersen sliding doors extend the living space onto a large Trex deck—an ideal setting for morning coffee, sunset dinners and relaxed waterside entertaining. There is also a Half Bathroom on the first floor as well as interior access to the finished Garage. Upstairs, the spacious Primary Ensuite features dual walk-in-closets, a Full Bath with double vanity and a comfortable seating nook. Three additional Bedrooms and a Full Bathroom complete the 2nd level. Additional highlights include: four-zone heating, ductless air conditioning, a Navien tankless hot-water system and a new roof installed in 2026. The property boasts 60 Feet of Waterfront with well-maintained bulkhead, offering convenient access for docking, launching and enjoying life on the water. Additionally, there is a paver driveway and side yard walkway. Convenient access to the LIRR, restaurants, shopping, schools, and Town of Oyster Bay parks and beaches, this Massapequa waterfront home captures the ease and beauty of South Shore living.

12 Jetmore Place, Massapequa

14 Jomarr Court, Massapequa
$2,599,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1039548 MLS
Welcome to 14 Jomarr Court, an extraordinary modern waterfront retreat offering its own private sandy beach, 60-foot pier with two floating Jet Ski docks, and spectacular resort-style backyard. Featuring 4 generously sized bedrooms, 4 full baths and a spacious loft, this exceptional residence combines sophisticated contemporary design, smart-home technology and an incredible waterfront lifestyle. Step inside to a dramatic, light-filled open-concept floor plan where clean architectural lines, oversized windows and doors, designer lighting and a striking floating staircase with glass railings create an impressive modern aesthetic. The expansive living, dining and kitchen areas flow seamlessly together, designed for both everyday living and effortless entertaining. At the heart of the home is a stunning designer kitchen featuring quartz countertops, an oversized waterfall island, custom cabinetry and top-of-the-line Thermador appliances. Oversized windows and glass doors capture beautiful water views while creating a seamless connection between the interior and outdoor living spaces. Upstairs, the spacious open loft with glass railings overlooks the main level and adds another dramatic architectural element. All four bedrooms are generously proportioned, while the luxurious primary suite is a true waterfront sanctuary. Vaulted ceilings and oversized glass doors open directly onto an incredible wraparound balcony overlooking the water, private beach, pool and grounds. The spa-inspired primary bath is beautifully appointed with floor-to-ceiling stone, double vanity, oversized glass-enclosed shower with multiple shower fixtures, designer finishes, smart toilet and radiant heat. Technology and comfort have been thoughtfully integrated throughout the home with a Savant smart-home system, Lutron lighting, surround sound throughout the interior and exterior, and radiant heat throughout the entire first floor and primary bath. Step outside and the property transforms into your own private waterfront resort. The spectacular 14’ x 28’ saltwater infinity-edge pool, approximately 5 feet deep, is surrounded by expansive lounging and entertaining areas, a fire pit and a covered outdoor living space. Beyond the pool, your private sandy beach leads directly to the waterfront and 60-foot pier with two floating Jet Ski docks, creating an exceptional setting for boating, water sports, entertaining or simply relaxing by the water. Additional features include two sump pumps, a French drain system and the added benefit of being outside the designated flood zone. From its private beach, infinity-edge pool and boating amenities to its sophisticated interiors, smart-home technology and exceptional indoor-outdoor flow, 14 Jomarr Court delivers the ultimate Long Island waterfront lifestyle — a home designed to feel like a private resort every day.

14 Jomarr Court, Massapequa

89 Ocean Avenue Unit #A, Massapequa
$1,350,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1018721 MLS
Move right into this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 3-bath waterfront Hi-Ranch offering the perfect blend of modern style, comfort, and coastal living. Completely updated with quality finishes and thoughtful upgrades throughout, this turnkey home is ready to enjoy. The stunning eat-in kitchen features quartz countertops, a classic subway tile backsplash, brand-new stainless steel appliances, a center island, and new Pella sliding glass doors that open to a spacious new deck—ideal for indoor-outdoor entertaining. Take in breathtaking sunrises and scenic water views while enjoying your morning coffee, dining on the deck, or relaxing from the comfort of the dining room. Located just a few houses from the open bay, this home offers the best of waterfront living on a generous property. Gleaming hardwood floors extend throughout the living room, dining room, and bedrooms. The primary suite includes two closets, a ceiling fan, and a beautifully renovated en-suite bath. Additional updates include thermal-pane windows and doors, recessed lighting, ceiling fans, new insulation, all-new plumbing, a brand-new 200-amp electrical service, and central air conditioning. The lower level offers a spacious family room with ceramic tile flooring, a renovated full bath with a walk-in shower, and new sliding glass doors leading to a brand-new patio. A dedicated laundry room with a brand-new washer and dryer and direct access to the attached two-car garage add everyday convenience. Additional highlights include an in-ground sprinkler system, a 35-foot bulkhead, and access to the Biltmore Beach Club. Located in School District 23, this exceptional waterfront home combines modern updates, beautiful views, and an unbeatable location—simply unpack and enjoy!

89 Ocean Avenue Unit #A, Massapequa

69 Ocean Avenue, Massapequa
$1,985,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1009632 MLS
Welcome to 69 Ocean Avenue, a stunning 3,500-square-foot custom waterfront residence thoughtfully renovated in “Prairie-style” architecture inspired by the renowned architect Frank Lloyd Wright. This home is a boat owner’s “dream come true” because it is on Massapequa Cove, a natural waterfront estuary part of the Great South Bay. This home has an 80 foot long pier, an 11,500 pound capacity 'HighTide' brand electric boat lift, and 90+ feet of bulk-heading separating the beach and bay waters from this home’s low maintenance back yard. The entire Great South Bay is your saltwater pool when you live here! The popular private Biltmore Beach Club is nearby and provides members beach, poolside and fun families clubhouse activities. This exceptional home has 5 bedrooms and 4 full bathrooms with its modern open-concept design. Its soaring 9- to 10-foot ceilings and walls of windows and glass doors capture expansive waterfront views from nearly every room. The double door grand entryway foyer provides you with two coat closets, a wide curved staircase with Art Deco-inspired railings, and beautiful 5.5-inch engineered maple flooring that extends throughout much of the home. The kitchen features cherry shaker-style cabinetry, quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, a peninsula with seating for four, and a spacious walk-in pantry. Perfect for entertaining - the main floor’s expansive living and dining areas are highlighted by a floor to ceiling stacked stone gas fireplace while the lower level's large den (or family room) offers elegant porcelain tile flooring. The large luxurious primary bedroom suite measures 26’ by 17’ and serves as a private retreat featuring a gas fireplace, two large walk-in closets, and a en-suite bath complete with a skylight and gorgeous water views. Step outside to the primary bedroom’s large covered lanai with stainless steel railings overlooking 95 feet of pristine waterfront, an 80-foot pier, and great views of the Cove and the Great South Bay. Enjoy breathtaking morning sunrises from your own backyard paradise. Additional highlights include 2 laundry rooms with the second-floor laundry room having a kitchenette, a 2-car garage with shelving and kayak storage, a large double-door storage shed attached to left side of house, a central vacuum, ADT monitored alarm system with 8 cameras, 2 Aprilaire air filtration systems, 2 built in humidifiers, a level 2 EV charger, and an owned rooftop solar system generating 12+ megawatts of electricity annually, complemented by a whole-house LG brand battery backup system. This smart home seamlessly combines luxury, sustainability, and energy efficiency in an unparalleled waterfront setting. Great for NYC commuters, being less than 2 miles from the Massapequa LIRR commuter parking lot!

69 Ocean Avenue, Massapequa

5 Division Avenue, Massapequa
$1,900,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1007431 MLS
To Be Built – Custom Luxury Bayfront Residence in Massapequa Shores Rare opportunity to build your dream waterfront home in the highly sought-after Massapequa Shores community. Situated on a generous 9,000 sq. ft. bayfront lot with 60 feet of new Navy bulkhead and private dock, this customizable residence offers approximately 3,000 sq. ft. of thoughtfully designed living space and breathtaking waterfront living. The proposed floor plan features 4 spacious bedrooms, 2.5 baths, and an impressive grand foyer entrance that sets the tone for the home’s elegant design. The luxurious primary suite includes two walk-in closets and a spa-inspired en-suite bath. Entertain with ease in the formal living room and formal dining room, or relax in the inviting den complete with a gas fireplace. Additional highlights include a covered front porch, two-car garage, and a variety of customizable finish packages, allowing buyers to personalize selections and create a home tailored to their lifestyle. Perfectly positioned in the acclaimed Massapequa School District, this exceptional location offers the best of South Shore living. Enjoy nearby waterfront recreation at Florence Beach and Anchor Park, while local favorites such as the iconic All American Drive-In and Marshall’s Ice Cream are just minutes away. Convenient access to shopping, dining, parks, beaches, and transportation further enhances this outstanding offering. Experience the ultimate combination of luxury, customization, and waterfront living—an extraordinary opportunity to build new on the open bay in one of Massapequa’s most desirable waterfront neighborhoods.

5 Division Avenue, Massapequa

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.