Garden City Apartments & Homes for Rent

Looking for a rental in Garden City, NY?

Garden City offers a mix of apartment rentals, individual houses, condos, co-ops, and other rental opportunities, although available inventory can change quickly.

Whether you're looking for an apartment close to shopping and restaurants, a house with more space, or a rental while you decide whether Garden City is the right long-term fit, understanding the local market can make the search much easier.

I’m John Cordeira, Broker/Owner of Cordeira Homes, and I’ve been helping Long Island buyers, sellers and renters for more than 20 years.

View Current Garden City Rentals

Current Apartments & Homes for Rent in Garden City

Rental inventory in Garden City changes frequently.

The listings displayed on this page are intended to show current rental opportunities rather than a fixed list that may quickly become outdated.

Depending on the market, available properties may include apartments, single-family houses, condos, co-ops or townhome-style rentals.

If you do not see the right property today, that does not necessarily mean one will not become available soon.

What Types of Rentals Are Available in Garden City?

Garden City has several different kinds of rental housing.

  • Apartment communities
  • Individual apartments within smaller buildings
  • Single-family houses for rent
  • Condo rentals
  • Co-op rentals where permitted
  • Townhome-style properties

The amount of inventory in each category can vary considerably, so I would not limit the search too narrowly at the beginning unless you already know exactly what type of property you want.

Apartment or House: Which Rental Is Right for You?

An apartment may make sense if convenience and lower maintenance are priorities.

A house may offer more space, privacy, outdoor area or parking, but may also come with different responsibilities and a higher monthly cost.

There is no universally better option.

The right choice depends on your budget, space requirements, location preferences and how long you expect to rent.

What Should I Consider Before Renting in Garden City?

Monthly rent is only one part of comparing properties.

Depending on the rental, you may also want to consider:

  • Utilities
  • Parking
  • Laundry
  • Pet policies
  • Storage
  • Outdoor space
  • Lease length
  • Move-in costs
  • Building amenities
  • Distance to transportation
  • Proximity to shopping, restaurants and recreation

Two rentals with similar asking rents may offer very different overall value depending on what is included.

What Is the Rental Application Process Like?

The exact process depends on the landlord, property owner or building.

A rental application may require financial documentation, identification, income verification, credit information or other documentation permitted by law.

Condo and cooperative rentals can sometimes involve additional building or board procedures.

It is useful to understand those requirements early so you can prepare before finding a property you really want.

Condos, Co-ops & Townhomes in Garden City

Some renters eventually decide they would rather own than continue renting.

If apartment-style or lower-maintenance living appeals to you, my Garden City Condos, Co-ops & Townhomes guide explains the differences between those ownership types and what buyers should know.

Should I Rent or Buy in Garden City?

That depends on your plans.

Renting can provide flexibility and may make sense if you're new to the area, uncertain about how long you'll stay or simply not ready to purchase.

Buying may make more sense for someone planning to remain longer term and who is financially prepared for homeownership.

If you're considering both options, you can also review current Garden City homes for sale and compare what is available.

Interested in New Construction?

If your preference is something newer rather than an existing rental or resale property, take a look at my Garden City New Construction Homes resource.

True new construction inside Garden City can be limited, so that guide also looks at opportunities in nearby Nassau County communities.

What Is It Like to Live in Garden City?

A rental search is not only about the apartment or house.

You're also choosing the community around it.

That's why I've built several local Garden City guides covering the things residents actually use in everyday life.

Shopping, Dining & Nightlife

My Garden City Shopping, Dining & Nightlife Guide covers Seventh Street, Franklin Avenue, restaurants, cafés, bars and local businesses.

Roosevelt Field

For one of the largest shopping and dining destinations in the area, visit my Roosevelt Field Mall & Living Near Garden City Guide.

Gyms & Fitness

Fitness has been part of my life for decades and is a major part of my #RippedRealtor identity.

My Garden City Gyms, Fitness & Healthy Living Guide covers large health clubs, smaller strength-training facilities, Pilates, yoga, hot yoga and group fitness in and near Garden City.

You can also follow the fitness side of what I do on Instagram at @rippedrealtorofli.

Parks & Outdoor Recreation

My Garden City Parks, Trails & Outdoor Recreation Guide covers local parks, athletic facilities, Hempstead Plains Preserve, nearby Eisenhower Park and other outdoor resources.

Already Own a Rental Property in Garden City?

If you own a Garden City property and are considering selling rather than continuing to rent it, start with my Garden City Home Value resource.

You can also read my Selling a Home in Garden City guide for information about pricing, preparation, marketing and the selling process.

Get My Garden City Property Value

Frequently Asked Questions About Garden City Rentals

Are there apartments for rent in Garden City?

Yes. Garden City has apartment rental options, although available units and pricing can change frequently.

Are there houses for rent in Garden City?

Yes. Single-family houses do become available for rent in Garden City, but inventory may be more limited than apartment inventory at certain times.

Can I rent a condo or co-op in Garden City?

Sometimes. Rental and subletting policies vary by condominium or cooperative, so the individual property's rules should be reviewed before assuming a unit can be rented.

How much are apartments in Garden City?

Rental prices vary depending on property type, size, condition, location, amenities and current market inventory. Because rents can change quickly, current listings provide a better picture than a fixed average quoted on this page.

Are there short-term rentals in Garden City?

Lease lengths and short-term availability depend on the individual property and landlord. If you need a specific lease term, that should be part of the search from the beginning.

Where can I find current Garden City rental listings?

The rental listings displayed on this page are intended to show current available properties in Garden City as inventory changes.

Looking for a Rental in Garden City?

If you're looking for an apartment, house, condo or other rental in Garden City, I can help you look at the available options and narrow the search based on what matters most to you.

And if you're still deciding between renting and buying, we can look at both.

Ask John About Garden City Rentals

Know a Garden City Rental Community I Should Include?

I want these Garden City guides to include more than whatever happens to appear first in an online search.

If there is a rental building, apartment community or housing option in or around Garden City that you think should be included, let me know.

Local recommendations help these pages continue becoming more useful over time.

Tell Me About a Garden City Rental

John Cordeira
Broker/Owner, Cordeira Homes
#RippedRealtor
Current Apartments & Homes for Rent in Garden City

$2,500
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1055107 MLS
Spacious, private 2nd floor 1 bedroom apartment in the heart of Carle Place, featuring a ground-level private entrance and a peaceful setting above a currently vacant commercial space. An unbeatable commuter's location just a 6-minute walk to the Carle Place LIRR station with easy access to local shopping, dining, and major thoroughfares, this unit features flexible living with tenants paying their own electric and gas, and neighborhood street or public parking. Landlord is offering rent concession to help you purchase your own refrigerator and other approved upgrades.

480 Westbury Avenue Unit #1, Carle Place
$7,800
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1036254 MLS
Welcome to this spacious and inviting 4-bedroom, 3-full-bath split-level home, ideally located in the Western section of Garden City. The home may be rented furnished or unfurnished, short term leases will be considered. This home offers a gracious entry way leading to a living room with gas fireplace, dining room with sliding doors to an outside deck, and an eat in kitchen on the first level. The second level offers an oversized primary bedroom with ensuite bath and ample closets. There are two additional bedrooms and a full hall bath. They third level may be used for office space, bedroom or playroom. The lower level provides access to the two car garage, an additional guest bedroom and large family room. The laundry room, storage and gym area complete the basement. The oversized property offers a lovely yard for outdoor relaxation and entertaining.This home is close to LIRR train lines, dining shopping, parks and schools.

148 Lincoln Street, Garden City
$2,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1043207 MLS
Sunny And Bright 2 Bedroom Spacious Apartment Located on 2nd Floor.Recently Updated Kitchen With Stainless Steel Appliances And Updated Full Hall Bath. Refinished Hardwood Floors Throughout. Large Bedrooms With Ample Closets And 3 Additional Closets! Convenient To Shopping, Restaurants And Transportation. Use Of The Yard Is Permitted For Quiet Enjoyment, No Ball Playing

176 Nassau Boulevard Unit #1, Garden City S.
$4,800
1 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1051374 MLS
Immaculate Fully Furnished Duplex – A Must See! Experience five-star living in this beautifully updated duplex. The open-concept design features a sun-filled living room that flows seamlessly to your private patio, perfect for entertaining. The chef’s kitchen is fully renovated with custom cabinetry and premium appliances, while the stylish powder room adds a touch of elegance. Upstairs, enjoy a spacious primary bedroom with exceptional closets, an en-suite spa-inspired bathroom, and the convenience of a separate laundry area. This residence is in mint condition and ready to impress! Cable service is included in rent as well as parking.

111 Cherry Valley Avenue Unit #M6, Garden City
$3,700
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1049837 MLS
Living Room/Dining Room, Kitchen, 1 bedroom, 1 full bath, terrace, washer & dryer, Storage, Located right in the center of Garden City. Close to All. Parking Space included with a private entrance and 24 hr monitored security. Apartment has a terrace., Additional information: Appearance:Excellent

191 7th Street Unit #206, Garden City
$14,500
7 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1047152 MLS
Luxury rental in the heart of Garden City’s prime central section, this coveted Victorian offers over 4,400 square feet of living space on a 0.43-acre lot with 7 bedrooms and 4.5 baths. Featuring a designer kitchen, soaring 10’ ceilings, abundant natural light through oversized windows, second-floor laundry, and three levels of living, the home combines elegance with modern convenience. An unfinished basement and two-car garage provide ample storage, while outdoor living shines with a spacious rear deck for entertaining and charming wraparound porches in the front. Perfectly located near the LIRR and vibrant Seventh Street’s restaurants and shops, this property delivers both luxury and convenience.

92 6th Street, Garden City
$2,500
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1047136 MLS
Beautiful Apartment in the heart of Carle Place close to Transportation an supermarkets and shopping centers.

480 Westbury Avenue, Carle Place
$5,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1041023 MLS
Welcome home to this spacious and beautifully maintained 5-bedroom, 2-bath Cape Cod in Garden City location, zoned for the award winning Stewart Manor Elementary School. Offering a flexible floor plan with generously sized rooms and plenty of space for both everyday living and entertaining, this home is in excellent condition and ready to enjoy. Additional highlights include a private backyard, attached garage, ample storage, and a convenient location close to the LIRR, shopping, dining, parks, and local amenities. With five bedrooms and two full baths, there’s plenty of room for a home office, guest space, or additional living areas. A wonderful opportunity to enjoy space, comfort, and convenience in a sought-after neighborhood.

43 Stewart Avenue, Garden City
$3,800
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1040102 MLS
Welcome to this bright and spacious second-floor 3-bedroom, 1-bath apartment on Nassau Blvd. Enjoy a convenient location close to the LIRR, buses, parks, shopping, and tons of restaurants, with easy access to everything the area has to offer. Located within the Sewanhaka Central High School District, serving H. Frank Carey High School. A great combination of space, location, and convenience!

137 Nassau Boulevard, Garden City S.
$16,500
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1039295 MLS
Exceptional young construction in the heart of the Estates! Built in 2020, this impressive Center Hall Brick Colonial offers over 5,000 square feet of beautifully designed living space featuring wide-plank white oak floors, soaring ceilings, and an open, flexible floor plan. The main level boasts a grand kitchen and great room with gas fireplace, convenient mudroom and laundry, plus a private bedroom with full bath ideal for guests, an au pair, or extended family. Upstairs, the luxurious primary suite features two walk-in closets and a spa-like en-suite bath, along with three additional bedrooms and two full baths. Second floor additional laundry closet. A finished attic provides fantastic bonus space, while the unfinished basement offers abundant storage. Set on a beautifully manicured 80x100 property with mature hedges and a paver patio, this exceptional home is ideally located near two train lines, including the express Merillon Avenue LIRR station with service to NYC in under 40 minutes.

198 Kensington Road, Garden City
$3,000
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1037516 MLS
LOCATION LOCATION! Rare opportunity to live in the center of downtown Garden City, on beautiful 7th street. This one bedroom, 1 bathroom unit truly offers it all. Large entry foyer, living room with adjacent dining area, completely updated kitchen overlooking Seventh Street. Primary bedroom has large closets and is adjacent to full updated hallway bathroom. Security camera to front lobby in unit. Laundry on first floor of renovated lobby. Located a block from LIRR, and immediately proximate to amazing restaurants, coffee shops, bakery, shopping and so much more. Don't miss this one! Does not come around often!

222 Seventh Street Unit #2C, Garden City
$7,500
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1036035 MLS
Garden City single family house move in ready. This beautiful house first floor features a living room with fireplace, dining room, open kitchen with nice island, pantry and half bath. All four bedrooms on upstairs. Hardwood floors and warm white walls throughout. Central AC. Gas cooking range. Total four bedrooms and a sunroom, 3.5bathrooms. Dry and washer in basement. Tenant pays gas, electric. Available to move in right the way.

210 Clinton Road, Garden City
Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.