Bay Shore Homes for Sale

Welcome to Bay Shore, a vibrant community nestled in Suffolk County, New York, where education meets opportunity! Known for its exceptional school district, Bay Shore is home to a diverse range of educational programs that cater to the needs of every student. The Bay Shore School District is dedicated to fostering a nurturing environment that encourages academic excellence, creativity, and personal growth. With a strong emphasis on STEM education, arts, and athletics, students are equipped with the skills they need to thrive in a rapidly changing world.

Families seeking homes in Bay Shore will find a variety of options that cater to different lifestyles and budgets. From charming single-family homes to modern townhouses, the real estate market in Bay Shore offers something for everyone. Many properties boast spacious yards, perfect for outdoor activities and family gatherings, while others feature contemporary designs with luxurious amenities.

The community itself is rich in culture and history, providing residents with access to beautiful parks, local shops, and delightful dining options. Plus, with its close proximity to the picturesque shores of the Great South Bay, residents can enjoy a wealth of recreational activities, from boating to fishing and everything in between.

If you’re looking to settle in a community that prioritizes education and offers a welcoming atmosphere, Bay Shore is the perfect place to call home. Explore the homes for sale today and discover the charm and convenience that this remarkable area has to offer!

Newest Bay Shore Homes for Sale

$765,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1062484 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully fully renovated Colonial in Bay Shore, offering modern finishes, thoughtful design, and a bright, inviting atmosphere throughout. This home features an open-concept living and dining area, hardwood floors throughout, recessed lighting, and a beautifully updated kitchen with white cabinetry, quartz-style countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a stylish subway tile backsplash. Offering 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and a versatile den/flex space, the home provides a comfortable and functional layout. Additional highlights include tastefully renovated bathrooms, a spacious walk-in shower, ceiling fans, convenient second-floor laundry, two-zone heating, and a Navien on-demand hot water system. Enjoy the charm of Colonial-style living with the comfort and appeal of modern updates. A wonderful opportunity to make this beautifully updated home your own!

4 Lee Avenue, Bay Shore

$1,950,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1063143 MLS

Discover a distinctive Fire Island Pines retreat where architectural character meets effortless coastal living. Soaring vaulted ceilings, sun-filled white interiors, curated artwork, and expansive glass doors create an inviting atmosphere. Multiple living and entertaining spaces flow seamlessly onto private outdoor decking surrounded by lush coastal landscaping. Weathered wood fencing, mature greenery, and natural vegetation create an intimate, tranquil setting that celebrates the island's unspoiled beauty. Enjoy outdoor dining, lounging, and a refreshing open-air shower after a day at the beach. Rich in personality and thoughtfully integrated into its natural surroundings, this unique residence offers privacy, understated sophistication, and the relaxed elegance of Fire Island living.

409 Ocean Walk Walk, Fire Island Pines

$625,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1062734 MLS

Welcome to this charming single family ranch! This home features a living room area that flows into the dinning room with an eat in kitchen. Three comfortable bedrooms and one full bath. A full size basemnt with a one car garage. Enjoy your afternoons in the private backyard. Conveniently located near shopping. Ideal for first-time buyers. Good for anyone that is interested in downsizing or for savy investors. Don't miss your chance to make this your own!

35 Circle Lane, Bay Shore

$700,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1062728 MLS

116 S Clinton Ave is a 2-story Bay Shore home with a kitchen connected to spacious living and dining areas. White cabinetry and counters arranged along three sides give the kitchen a defined preparation area without separating it from the main rooms. A front dining nook and windows along the living area bring light into the open layout. Upstairs sleeping areas include the primary bedroom, while main-level bedroom space adds flexibility to the floor plan. A dedicated laundry area sits near the rear entrance. Outside, a rear patio meets the fenced backyard, creating space to enjoy the lawn.

116 S Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore

$779,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1062234 MLS

Lovingly maintained by the same owner for over 50 years, this charming 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath split-level is located in the desirable West Bay Shore area, just blocks from Brightwaters Village. Situated on a beautiful .34-acre park-like property, this home offers plenty of space, privacy, and endless possibilities. Updates completed in 2017 include the roof, siding, windows, and bathroom. Additional features include central air conditioning, an attached garage, oil heat, and natural gas cooking. Natural gas is already in the home, offering the potential for conversion from oil heat. Public sewers—no septic system! A wonderful opportunity to make this well-cared-for home your own in a sought-after location.

991 Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore

$1,050,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1062487 MLS

Ability to expand to 1980 sq ft

84 Oak Walk, Bay Shore

$510,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1062298 MLS

Home sold "As Is" Needs some TLC and updating but offers great potential. Come and see. Please use Showing time for scheduling.

1761 Manatuck Boulevard, Babylon

$899,998

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048854 MLS

Charming and spacious ranch located South of Montauk in one of Bay Shores most charming areas. Open floor plan with stone fireplace, wood floors and a bright airy floor plan.

87 Bayway Avenue, Bay Shore

$624,999

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1061716 MLS

Welcome home to this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch, thoughtfully updated in 2018 from top to bottom. The extensive renovations include new doors, Andersen windows, roof, siding, HVAC system, and radiant heated floors, providing comfort and peace of mind. The inviting kitchen is a true standout, featuring an oversized quartz island that serves as the perfect centerpiece for meal preparation, casual dining, and entertaining. The vaulted ceilings enhance the home's open, airy feel, while ample storage ensures plenty of room to keep everything organized and in its place. The primary bedroom with private ensuite is located on the north side of the house and the other two guest bedrooms on the south side of the house, there is plenty of privacy for all. Step outside to enjoy the composite front deck, an ideal spot to relax and unwind. Enjoy relaxing nights in the tranquil backyard around the store fire pit. There is additional storage in the shed outside. With major updates already completed and thoughtful features throughout, this exceptional home offers the ease of turnkey living without the hassle of renovations. This move-in-ready home offers the perfect blend of style, comfort, and functionality. Simply unpack and enjoy all this beautifully updated ranch has to offer!

1435 Brooklyn Boulevard, Bay Shore

$799,999

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1005955 MLS

Don't miss this single-family home located at 1624 E 3rd Avenue, Bay Shore. Situated on a spacious lot, this property offers great potential and is conveniently located near shopping, transportation, schools, and major roadways. Whether you're searching for your next home or an investment opportunity, this property is definitely worth seeing

1624 E 3rd Avenue, Bay Shore

$3,000,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1052186 MLS

Effortless oceanfront living tucked between Fire Island Pines and Davis Park. Water Island is one of Fire Island’s most secluded and distinctive communities, with just 48 homes bordering the protected Fire Island National Seashore, located only 90 minutes from New York City. Surrounded by pristine beaches, dunes, and the Atlantic Ocean, this rare setting offers a true sense of escape and privacy. Set on nearly 100’ of oceanfront property, this four-bedroom, four-bath residence is an exceptional retreat designed for relaxed entertaining and effortless summer living. Designed by acclaimed architect Scott Bromley of Bromley Caldari Architects, this house balances clean modern lines with an extraordinary warmth of natural wood and handcrafted details. Approximately 2,100 square feet of interior living space is surrounded by generous outdoor spaces, creating a home that is as much about outdoor living as it is about interior luxury. Clear cedar clapboard siding, mahogany decks, custom wood entry gates, and wood-framed Reilly windows and doors establish a sophisticated yet organic presence among the dunes. Inside, the architectural palette continues with Gothic European oak flooring and cedar tongue-and-groove walls accented with hardwood detailing. Solid wood doors, custom wood stair treads and railings, and custom-fabricated wood veneer cabinetry bring a sense of craftsmanship to every room. The combination of warm woods, crisp white walls, and carefully selected stone and metal accents creates a modern coastal aesthetic that feels polished without ever feeling formal. The heart of the home is designed for gathering. The open living area centers around a gas fireplace clad in Brazilian slate, while the custom kitchen features wood veneer cabinetry, Caesarstone countertops, and premium Sub-Zero, Gaggenau, Wolf, and Miele appliances. Expansive glass doors open directly to the outdoor entertaining spaces, making the transition from indoors to out virtually seamless. Outside, a spectacular 25' x 9' gunite pool anchors the main deck and creates a private oasis for long summer afternoons. The custom outdoor kitchen is equipped with wood cabinetry, a Concrete Collaborative cast-concrete countertop, Weber grill, under-counter refrigerator, and ice maker—everything needed for effortless entertaining without ever leaving the poolside. Generous mahogany decking provides multiple areas for dining, lounging, and soaking in the surrounding landscape. The four bedrooms provide comfortable accommodations for guests, with each space thoughtfully designed to complement the home’s distinctive character. Four full baths feature custom cabinetry, stone countertops, and custom teak sink vessels, continuing the home’s carefully curated material palette throughout. From the standing-seam Invarimate metal roof and clear cedar exterior to the custom woodwork found throughout the interiors, this residence is a study in thoughtful design and craftsmanship. A private Water Island escape created for gathering, entertaining, and embracing the easy rhythm of life by the ocean. Also offered separately: The adjacent property is also available for purchase under a separate MLS listing (#1052145) 0 Charach Walk ($2.5M). Buyers interested in both properties are encouraged to review the separate listing for additional details (#910335) 0 Charach & 1 West Walk ($5.2M).

1 West Walk, Water Island

$2,500,000

1 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1052145 MLS

Water Island Awaits. A private oceanfront retreat tucked between Fire Island Pines and Davis Park, Water Island is one of Fire Island’s most secluded and distinctive enclaves, with just 48 homes bordering the protected Fire Island National Seashore. Here, the rhythm of the ocean creates a unique sense of remoteness and natural beauty, while New York City remains within easy reach. Set directly along the Atlantic, this remarkable one-bedroom residence is an intimate architectural retreat designed to embrace its natural surroundings. Designed by acclaimed architect Scott Bromley of Bromley Caldari Architects, the Main House draws inspiration from the organic craftsmanship of George Nakashima and Hans Wegner, pairing modernist simplicity with an exceptional warmth of natural materials. Throughout the approximately 1,500-square-foot residence, clear cedar, European oak, mahogany, and other finely crafted woods create a refined yet deeply relaxed coastal aesthetic. Whitewashed clear cedar tongue-and-groove walls are accented with hardwood detailing, while solid wood doors, custom wood veneer cabinetry, and a sculptural custom staircase add layers of craftsmanship throughout the home. The result is architecture that feels both sophisticated and completely at home in its dune setting. The first floor is devoted to a serene private en-suite, with spa-like bathing spaces featuring custom cabinetry, Dale Rogers Ammonite stone countertops, custom cast-concrete sinks, and a seamless connection to the outdoors. A private concrete collaborative outdoor plunge pool is framed by a cedar slatted privacy barrier, creating an intimate place to unwind. Indoor and outdoor overhead rain showers offer the quintessential Fire Island experience, with the two spaces seamlessly connected yet privately separated by an elegant sliding glass door. Upstairs, the home opens dramatically to the landscape. Floor-to-ceiling windows and an expansive ocean-facing glass door blur the boundary between indoors and out. Beneath a dramatic cathedral ceiling, the ocean becomes the defining backdrop, while an oversized Noguchi pendant floats overhead as a sculptural focal point. The chef’s kitchen continues the home’s thoughtful material palette with custom-fabricated wood veneer cabinetry, Caesarstone countertops, and a suite of premium Wolf, Sub-Zero, and Miele appliances. The open living and dining areas flow naturally onto expansive mahogany decks, where the ocean and surrounding dunes become part of everyday life. The Home features a clear cedar clapboard exterior and distinctive wood-framed Reilly windows and doors. A standing-seam Invarimate metal roof completes the exterior, reflecting the same thoughtful craftsmanship and attention to detail found throughout the interiors. Every material was chosen to complement the surrounding landscape while creating a home that feels both refined and deeply connected to its coastal setting. Here, architecture, natural materials, and the beauty of Water Island come together to create an exceptional private retreat. Also offered separately: The adjacent property is also available for purchase under a separate MLS listing (#1052186) 1 West Walk ($3M). Buyers interested in both properties are encouraged to review the separate listing for additional details (#910335) 0 Charach & 1 West Walk ($5.2M).

Charach Walk, Water Island

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.