Amityville Homes under $800,000

Welcome to Amityville, a charming village nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. Known for its rich history and picturesque waterfront, Amityville offers a unique blend of small-town charm and modern living. With its tree-lined streets, friendly community, and vibrant local culture, this neighborhood is a hidden gem on Long Island.

Amityville is renowned for its scenic views along the Great South Bay, providing residents with ample opportunities for outdoor activities, from boating and fishing to leisurely strolls along the waterfront. The village boasts a variety of parks, including the popular Amityville Beach, where families gather for summer fun and relaxation. Its proximity to the Long Island Rail Road makes commuting to New York City a breeze, making it an ideal location for professionals seeking a peaceful retreat after a busy day.

For those looking to call Amityville home, there are fantastic options available under $800,000. The real estate market here features a diverse range of homes, from charming bungalows and classic Colonials to modern townhouses, catering to various lifestyles and preferences. Buyers will appreciate the sense of community and the welcoming atmosphere that Amityville embodies.

In addition to its beautiful homes, Amityville offers a variety of local shops, restaurants, and cultural attractions, making it a vibrant place to live. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer or looking to downsize, Amityville presents an excellent opportunity to invest in a thriving neighborhood that feels like home. Come explore the warmth and charm of Amityville, where your dream home awaits!

Newest Amityville Homes under $800,000

$625,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1052621 MLS

Great Opportunity to be Close to Village, Super Clean Unit with Wood Floors, Full Basement, Granite EIK, Desirable Gas Heat and Cooking, Laundry on 2nd Floor, Hidden Gem ! Call to View Today.

176 Merrick Road Unit #10, Amityville

$589,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1052997 MLS

Embrace Home Ownership in the Incorporated Village of Amityville! Located in the vibrant community of Amityville, this home offers a perfect canvas for you to add your personal touches and create a space that reflects your unique style. The main floor boasts two spacious bedrooms, living room with a fireplace, an eat in kitchen with exit to rear sunroom. ****Additionally, a full walk-up granny attic awaits your vision! This versatile area presents an exciting opportunity to expand your living space—imagine two additional bedrooms or a luxurious master suite. The home also features a full basement, ideal for extra storage or the potential to be transformed into a recreation room, along with an attached one-car garage for added convenience. Enjoy it’s proximity to the charming downtown area; just a leisurely stroll to enjoy a variety of shops, restaurants, and local cafes. Whether you're craving a delicious meal, looking to indulge in some retail therapy, or simply want to soak up the community atmosphere, everything is just a short walk away. As a resident of Amityville, you'll also enjoy exclusive access to the Amityville Beach—perfect for swimming, sunbathing, and water sports during the warm months. Plus, the perks of living in the Town of Babylon, which includes access to parks, recreational facilities, ocean beaches and numerous community events designed to enhance your lifestyle. Don't miss the chance to make this house your own in a community that thrives on connection and enjoyment—your bright future awaits!

12 Benjamin Avenue, Amityville

$599,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1046768 MLS

This sweet cape in Amityville Village is completely turn key, the kind of home where the work has already been done and all that's left is moving in. Wide molding frames the updated windows throughout, and wood floors carry across the entire first floor. The kitchen was updated in 2013 with granite countertops, cabinets and backsplash. The bathroom was fully renovated in 2024. The roof was replaced in 2001, and gas heat keeps things efficient year round, and even the blinds operate by remote. Out front, a screened in porch gives the home a distinctly Amityville feel, a private, bug free spot to sit that most capes simply don't offer. The layout includes two bedrooms plus a loft that converts easily into a third bedroom, home office, or guest space. Outside, an automatic black metal gate secures the yard, a back deck and retractable awning stretch the living space through the warmer months, and a nice sized detached 2.5 car garage with its own loft that adds storage most buyers won't expect. LOW Taxes run under $10,000 combined for town and village on a 50 x 145 lot it is unbeatable!

56 Washington Avenue, Amityville

$619,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1035818 MLS

Seize the opportunity at 27 S Ketcham Ave, where charm meets modern living! This home is a canvas for your dreams, featuring a sun-lit eat-in kitchen that invites culinary creativity and spirited gatherings with family and friends. Imagine cozy evenings in the inviting living room, which flows effortlessly into a spacious rear family room complete with a fireplace—perfect for those chilly nights. Step outside thru the rear sliders to the Trex deck, where you can unwind amidst the lush, private backdrop of your generous 91’x196’ property, offering a serene retreat from the hustle and bustle. With 3 charming bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, this home provides ample space for those seeking a peaceful sanctuary. The attached 1-car garage adds to your convenience, and the hardwood floors throughout create an elegant ambiance that will make you feel right at home. Experience year-round comfort with efficient gas/hw heating. Perfectly situated in the heart of the village, you'll have easy access to a variety of shopping, dining, and transportation options, allowing you to explore all that Amityville has to offer. This is more than just a house—it's a chance to secure your future in a vibrant community. Don’t miss out on this incredible opportunity—your ideal home awaits!

27 S Ketcham Avenue, Amityville

$225,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1030264 MLS

Affordable homeownership is increasingly hard to find on Long Island's South Shore, and this second-floor, garden-style one-bedroom co-op at 297 Merrick Rd in the Village of Amityville offers a rare entry point at an accessible price. Wood floors run throughout the unit, and the spacious bedroom easily accommodates a king-sized bed with ample closet space. Located close to local shopping, dining, and everyday Amityville village amenities, this co-op is also within walking distance of the private, locals-only beach, home to the Village's Supper by the Bay waterfront gatherings and relaxed summer evenings. On-site laundry and additional private storage in the basement round out the building's everyday conveniences. Co-ops at this price point are limited on Long Island, and this one comes with the numbers to back it up: the monthly maintenance covers Town of Babylon taxes, Village of Amityville taxes, exterior maintenance, common area maintenance, snow removal, water, sewer, and heat. A straightforward opportunity to own instead of rent, in a village worth living in.

297 Merrick Road Unit #D 1, Amityville

$420,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 992241 MLS

Welcome to 58 Harbor N in the desirable Snug Harbor community, a 55+ waterfront condominium in the Incorporated Village of Amityville offering a relaxed, and easy lifestyle. This one-bedroom, one-full-bath end unit is an excellent opportunity to renovate and make it your own. Features include a spacious living and dining area, a generously sized primary bedroom with two large closets, and an in-unit washer and dryer. A sliding glass door opens to a private rear patio, and the unit also includes a large outdoor storage closet and one assigned parking space. Residents enjoy a wide range of amenities, including a clubhouse with a full kitchen and gathering areas, gym, in-ground swimming pool, billiard room, library, tennis courts, and a private marina. Boat slips are available for an additional cost, subject to availability and association requirements. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, parks, and transportation, this home offers a great opportunity for buyers to update and customize the space to suit their own style and vision.

58 Harbor Road N, Amityville

$699,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1020417 MLS

Welcome to The Rowand Retreat — because some homes deserve more than just an address, they deserve a name. Perfectly situated at the end of a quiet canal in Amity Harbor, this waterfront home captures a rare straightaway view down the canal, creating a peaceful and scenic setting that is hard to come by. Offering 90’ of bulkhead, this property was designed to fully embrace waterfront living. Thoughtfully cared for and filled with warmth, this is more than just a house — it is a home. And now, the opportunity is yours to make it your own. This ranch offers easy one-level living with hardwood floors throughout and a layout designed for both comfort and functionality. The updated kitchen features butcher block countertops, stainless steel appliances, gas cooking, and under-cabinet lighting with a timeless design that perfectly complements the home’s waterfront setting. Just off the kitchen is a convenient mud room with access to both the backyard and attached 1.5-car garage. Additional highlights include an updated bathroom, Pella and Andersen windows, central air conditioning, sewers, an updated boiler and hot water system, a 9-year-old roof, and leaf guards with a transferable warranty. Outside, the property was designed to fully embrace waterfront living. Featuring updated siding with brick accents, paver walkways, a fully fenced PVC yard, and two asphalt driveways, the exterior offers both beauty and functionality. The 16x16 shed is equipped with electric and supported by its own pilings, while additional electric has been extended to the dock and deck areas through a 200-amp service — ideal for entertaining and waterfront living. Additional highlights include in-ground 5-zone sprinklers, a security system, and 90’ of bulkhead framing this exceptional canal-front setting. True taxes $11,602.

19 Buchanan Avenue, Amity Harbor

$617,200

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1021456 MLS

Colonial-style single-family residence offering approximately 2,316 square feet of living space with 4 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms. Situated on an approximately 6,100-square-foot lot, this two-story home provides a functional layout with multiple living areas and a full basement offering additional storage and utility space. Built in 2005, the property features public water and sewer service, frame construction, and a residential setting within the Village of Amityville area. Conveniently located near local roadways, shopping, transportation options, parks, schools, and a variety of community services. The surrounding area is characterized primarily by one- and two-family residential housing with stable market conditions and balanced supply and demand.

56 E Smith Street, Amityville

$769,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 000173 MLS

Discover Your Dream Home in Amityville! Step into this stunning one-story ranch-style gem, nestled on 0.63 acres of beautifully landscaped paradise in the heart of Amityville. Perfect for entertaining. The expansive backyard boasts a large deck, a charming brick patio with a fire pit, and ample space for a pool. Plus access to the house with 2 separate driveways. Recently renovated, this home features a modern loft area, a brand-new roof, and exquisite new flooring throughout. Enjoy the convenience of a spacious detached garage and a partially finished lower level, ideal for a kids’ playroom, complete with a full bathroom and laundry room. Located on a serene street, this property offers easy access to vibrant shops, delightful restaurants, a train station, a bus terminal, and top-rated schools. Don’t miss the opportunity to make this exceptional home yours! Owners Motivated

81 Union Avenue, Amityville

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.