Wantagh Homes for Sale

Welcome to Wantagh, New York—a charming hamlet nestled in the heart of Nassau County that perfectly blends suburban tranquility with vibrant community spirit. Known for its picturesque streets and friendly neighborhoods, Wantagh offers residents a unique lifestyle characterized by a rich history, excellent schools, and an abundance of recreational activities. With its close proximity to beautiful beaches, parks, and the iconic Jones Beach State Park, outdoor enthusiasts will find plenty to explore right at their doorstep.

Wantagh boasts a diverse array of homes for sale, making it an ideal destination for families, young professionals, and retirees alike. From cozy single-family homes to spacious modern residences, the real estate options cater to various tastes and budgets. Many properties feature lush gardens, updated kitchens, and inviting living spaces, perfect for both entertaining and relaxation. The community is also known for its top-rated schools, ensuring that families have access to quality education just moments away from home.

As you explore the homes for sale in Wantagh, you'll discover a welcoming atmosphere that fosters a sense of belonging. With its vibrant local shops, delightful dining options, and easy access to public transportation, Wantagh is not just a place to live—it's a place to thrive. Whether you’re looking for a starter home or a forever residence, Wantagh offers the perfect backdrop for your next chapter. Come and experience the charm of Wantagh, where community, convenience, and comfort come together seamlessly!

Newest Wantagh Homes for Sale

$720,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1061907 MLS

Welcome to 2450 Mermaid Avenue in Wantagh! This home offers comfortable living in a desirable location, featuring natural gas and low property taxes. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, parks, and major roadways, this property is a fantastic opportunity to make your new home.

2450 Mermaid Avenue, Wantagh

$949,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1063220 MLS

Beautifully Renovated Split-Level Home in Wantagh! Welcome to 3681 Richard Lane, a stunning 4 bedroom, 3-bathroom home offering approximately 2,450 sq. ft. of living space. Extensively renovated in 2024, this move-in-ready home features a new roof, gas heating system, central air conditioning, flooring, two new bathrooms, and a brand-new chef’s kitchen with center island, JennAir stove, and stainless steel appliances. The main residence offers 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, a spacious eat-in kitchen, and a bright living room with cathedral ceilings, 2 skylights, hardwood floors, gas fireplace, and deck access. The lower level features a private entrance, 2 bedrooms, living room, dining area, full kitchen with stainless steel appliances, full bathroom with tub, and washer/dryer combo. Enjoy a private backyard with an expansive composite deck, pergola, outdoor entertaining areas, mature landscaping, and storage shed. A wonderful combination of modern comfort, flexible living space, and exceptional outdoor living!

3681 Richard Lane, Wantagh

$729,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1061891 MLS

Welcome To This Charming 3 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom Cape In Wantagh Woods! Featuring Gas Heat, Hardwood Flooring, Wood Burning Fireplace, Spacious Living Room, Eat In Kitchen, Formal Dining Room, 1 Bedroom On The Main Floor With 2 More Upstairs, Full Basement With Laundry, Large Driveway With 1 Car Garage, 6,300 Sq. Ft. Lot, In-Ground Lawn Sprinklers, PVC Fencing, Professionally Landscaped, All Close To Wantagh Village, LIRR, Schools, Parks, Restaurants & More!

1843 Beech Street, Wantagh

$899,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1048563 MLS

Welcome to Your Dream Home in Beautiful Mandalay! Move right into this beautifully updated 3 bedroom 3 bathroom home, ideally situated mid-block in one of Mandalay’s prime neighborhoods. Conveniently located near parks and beaches, this exceptional property combines modern updates with the perfect setting for comfortable living and entertaining. Enjoy an entirely updated interior featuring a stunning new kitchen, beautifully updated bathrooms, near-new roof and siding, electrical service and subpanels, and 200-amp electric. Additional highlights include gas heat, a gas stove, central air conditioning, and an automatic generator for added peace of mind. Continue outside to your own resort-style backyard featuring a sparkling in-ground pool, inviting patio, and awning—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. This move-in-ready gem offers the ideal blend of comfort, style, and location. A must-see home you won’t want to miss!

2452 Freeport Street, Wantagh

$999,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1059703 MLS

Welcome to this spacious 4 Bedroom, 2.5 Bath Splanch in the Twin Lakes Section, a well-designed layout designed for comfortable everyday living and entertaining. The Main level features a beautifully appointed Kitchen with custom cabinetry, a peninsula, and gas cooking. An adjacent Den with a wood-burning Fireplace keeps everyone connected, while a conveniently located half bathroom and laundry area complete the main area. Just a few steps above, the distinctive Splanch design reveals a generously sized living room. The upper level includes a spacious Primary Bedroom with a Full Bathroom, three additional well-proportioned bedrooms, and a full hallway bathroom. The partially finished Basement features high ceilings and flexible space ideal for a home gym, office, or recreation area. The home also features hardwood floors throughout, ample storage space and abundance of natural light. There is also an attached 1 car garage with interior access. Outside, enjoy a paver patio and generously sized yard with plenty of room for outdoor dining, entertaining, and relaxation. Convenient to all - Shopping, LIRR, Restaurants and more.

1675 Cornelius Avenue, Wantagh

$989,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1056556 MLS

Welcome To 2817 Riverside Dr! This Beautiful Turn-Key Hi Ranch Features 3 Bedrooms & 2.5 Bathrooms! A Bright & Spacious Living Room & Dining Room, Granite Eat-In Kitchen With Stainless Steel Appliances & Gas Cooking. Three Spacious Bedrooms Including A Primary En-Suite With Double Closets. The Ground Level Consists Of A Large Den With Gas Fireplace & Sliders Out To A Stunning Backyard, Half Bathroom, Laundry Room & Access To The 2-Car Garage. Solar Heated, Saltwater, In-Ground Swimming Pool, Outdoor Kitchen & Sitting Area Underneath A Pergola On A Private 6,000 Sq Ft Lot. Hardwood Flooring, Gas Cooking & Heating, New Central A/C, Koi Pond, & Owned Solar Panels For The Swimming Pool. Located In The Prime Mandalay Section Of Wantagh, Close To Schools, Parks & More!

2817 Riverside Drive, Wantagh

$799,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1057428 MLS

This is the expanded Cape in Wantagh you have been waiting for! Offering 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and approximately 1,548 square feet of living space, this home has plenty to offer. The first floor welcomes you with an inviting front porch and features a granite eat-in kitchen with tile backsplash, laminate flooring, gas cooking, dishwasher, and bay window. The formal dining room offers hardwood floors and a new wall A/C, while the extended living room features a pellet fireplace, newer carpeting, and a new wall A/C. Also on the first floor are a primary bedroom with hardwood floors and a closet, an additional bedroom/home office, and a full bathroom. The second floor features hardwood floors throughout, a bedroom with closet, wall A/C, and fresh paint, an additional bedroom with closet and wall A/C, plus a large hallway closet for extra storage. The full finished basement with heat offers a large open room, full bathroom, laundry area with a new washer, and utility room with a gas boiler and new separate hot water heater, plus an additional wall A/C. Other features include updated windows, crown molding, new ceiling fans, tons of storage, in-ground sprinklers in the front and back, a newer roof, and a 1.5-car garage with all-new roof plywood. Enjoy the private fenced-in backyard complete with a paver patio and two storage sheds!

3153 Ward Lane, Wantagh

$839,999

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1055221 MLS

Opportunity Knocks in Wantagh’s Twin Lakes Neighborhood! This custom 1,700+ sq. ft. expanded ranch with charming front porch, set on a quarter-acre property, offers 3 generous bedrooms, 2 spacious full baths, and a warm, character-filled interior highlighted by beautiful wood finishes throughout. The sunken living room showcases rich wood trim and detailing, hardwood floors, and a brick two-sided fireplace, wood-burning from the living room and with the potential for gas from the formal dining room. The kitchen continues the home’s natural warmth with an abundance of cherry cabinetry, Corian countertops, updated black and stainless-steel appliances, and a double oven. Just off the kitchen, the heated all-season room is a standout, featuring a traditional exposed wood-beam ceiling and brick flooring, an inviting space for entertaining or relaxing year round. Outside, enjoy a cement patio, PVC-fenced property, and an oversized two-car detached garage. Additional updates and features include a 2025 Whirlpool washer and dryer, hardwood flooring throughout, updated architectural roof, 2-zone gas hot-water heat, new hot-water heater, 3 wall A/C units, and 200-amp electric. Located in the Forest Lake Elementary School area, close to the LIRR, Wantagh Park, Twin Lakes Preserve, shopping, dining and just minutes from Jones Beach. True taxes: $17,304. Tax grievance in progress. A spacious home filled with warmth, woodwork, and character that truly must be seen to be appreciated.

3075 Wilson Avenue, Wantagh

$699,999

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1055910 MLS

WRAP UP THE SEARCH...YOU FOUND IT ON WHITE BIRCH! WELCOME TO THIS 4 BEDROOM, 2 FULL BATHROOM HOME IN WANTAGH WITH A FULL, PARTIALLY FINISHED BASEMENT FOR EXTRA LIVING SPACE AND STORAGE, PLUS A DETACHED GARAGE FOR EVEN MORE STORAGE AND PARKING! ADDITIONAL HIGHLIGHTS INCLUDE A NEWER ROOF, TWO NEWER DUCTLESS UNITS, IN-GROUND SPRINKLERS, HARDWOOD FLOORS UNDER THE CARPETS ON THE FIRST FLOOR, AND OIL HEAT WITH GAS COOKING AND A GAS DRYER! CONVENIENTLY LOCATED CLOSE TO SCHOOLS AND MAJOR PARKWAYS!

947 White Birch Lane, Wantagh

$699,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1055831 MLS

Welcome Home! This charming, well-maintained ranch in Wantagh’s most desirable neighborhoods offering a welcoming entry foyer, spacious living room & dining room featuring gleaming hardwood floors & a eat-in Kitchen. The primary bedroom has a full bathroom along with 2 additional bedrooms & a second full bathroom. The full basement offers an open layout w/endless possibility, including a laundry area & space ready to be finished. Additional features include a 1-car garage, spacious backyard with room to entertain & garden, inground sprinklers, 200-amp electric, CAC, updated roof & boiler. Conveniently located near shopping, parkways and LIRR. Don't miss your opportunity to make this wonderful home yours!

3566 Anita Lane, Wantagh

$749,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1055275 MLS

Wantagh living at its best! You'll enjoy being near Cedar Creek and Wantagh Park for endless recreation opportunities. Just minutes away is the "Gateway to Jones Beach," making summer beach days and waterfront adventures part of the Wantagh lifestyle. Located within the highly desirable Wantagh School District, the nearby elementary school on Beech St. adds another layer of everyday convenience. You'll enter into a welcoming living room that flows naturally into the eat-in kitchen, creating an easy, comfortable space for everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen features new appliances, with a convenient laundry room just beyond. The first floor offers two bedrooms and a full bath, providing flexible space for guests, a home office, or whatever suits your lifestyle. Upstairs, retreat to the oversized primary bedroom, complete with its own full bath and plenty of room to create a private sanctuary. With thoughtful upgrades including new appliances, new windows, new roof, and updated electrical service, this home offers peace of mind and an opportunity to enjoy the best of Wantagh in a home that's ready for its next chapter.

2230 Beech Street, Wantagh

$750,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1056367 MLS

Welcome to this inviting ranch-style home offering attractive curb appeal, comfortable living spaces, and beautifully maintained outdoor areas. The front exterior makes an immediate impression with a broad, manicured lawn, mature shade tree, neatly sculpted shrubs, and a clean driveway leading to the attached garage. A combination of siding and stone accents adds visual character, while the front entry is framed by established landscaping that gives the home a polished, well-cared-for appearance. Inside, the main living area feels warm and welcoming, with a spacious layout that flows easily into the dining area and kitchen. Recessed lighting, large windows, and soft neutral tones create a bright and comfortable atmosphere. The living room features a striking stone fireplace with built-in shelving and display space, adding both charm and function. This central gathering area offers room for everyday living as well as entertaining, with a seamless connection to the dining space. The dining area is positioned beside wide windows that bring in excellent natural light and create an open feel. Just beyond, the kitchen offers an efficient design with generous cabinet storage, extensive counter space, and room to move comfortably while preparing meals. White cabinetry gives the space a crisp, timeless look, while the layout includes plentiful upper and lower storage, a stainless refrigerator, a double sink beneath a window, and a convenient work island or center storage area that adds flexibility. Additional interior spaces provide versatility for a variety of needs. One room is ideal for a home office, reading room, den, or hobby space, while another enclosed sitting area offers a cozy retreat filled with natural light. These extra spaces enhance the overall functionality of the home and allow for multiple lifestyle uses without sacrificing comfort. The bedrooms shown are well proportioned and inviting, each with windows for natural light and layouts that allow for practical furniture placement. The primary bedroom presents a calm, spacious setting with a mirrored closet wall that helps reflect light and expand the feel of the room. Secondary bedrooms offer flexibility for guest space, work-from-home use, or additional everyday living needs. The bathrooms reflect tasteful updates and thoughtful design. One bath includes a beautifully finished walk-in shower with glass enclosure, attractive tilework, grab bars, and a stylish vanity with ample storage. A second bath adds convenience and functionality for the home’s overall layout. Outdoor living is another highlight of the property. The backyard includes a deck with space for seating, dining, and relaxing, all surrounded by lush greenery, privacy fencing, and carefully maintained landscaping. The lawn is neatly edged and framed by mature hedges and ornamental plantings, creating an appealing setting for outdoor enjoyment. Additional features visible in the photos include hardwood floors in several rooms, built-in shelving, a partially finished lower level with extra usable space, and an attached garage with storage potential. This is a home that blends comfort, character, and practical everyday living, both inside and out.

3473 S Hawthorne Drive S

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.