Baiting Hollow Homes under $800,000

Welcome to Baiting Hollow, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. This charming hamlet is known for its picturesque landscapes, serene atmosphere, and rich history, making it an ideal place for anyone seeking a peaceful retreat while still being within reach of the vibrant Long Island lifestyle. Baiting Hollow offers a unique blend of rural charm and modern conveniences, where residents can enjoy breathtaking views of the Long Island Sound and lush vineyards that dot the landscape.

For those in search of their dream home, Baiting Hollow presents an enticing opportunity with a selection of beautiful properties available for under $800,000. Whether you’re a first-time buyer, a growing family, or looking to downsize, you’ll find a variety of homes that cater to diverse tastes and lifestyles. From cozy cottages to spacious family residences, each property reflects the warmth and character that Baiting Hollow is known for.

Living in Baiting Hollow means you can enjoy leisurely days at the nearby beaches, explore the scenic trails, or indulge in the local wineries that have made this area a favorite among wine enthusiasts. The community is also conveniently located near shopping, dining, and entertainment options, ensuring that you have everything you need just a stone's throw away.

With its affordable housing options and idyllic surroundings, Baiting Hollow is not just a place to live—it's a lifestyle waiting to be embraced. Come discover the charm of Baiting Hollow and find the perfect home to start your next chapter!

Newest Baiting Hollow Homes under $800,000

$89,990

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1059569 MLS

Adorable and priced to move quickly! This cottage is offers 2 bedrooms with vaulted ceilings open living room to kitchen, spacious screened in room, Trex deck and back deck offer additional space to hang out and use the BBQ, plenty of parking with a fully paved driveway and additional spot in front, and great storage in your shed accented with crows nest accent. Enjoy the numerous local attractions including Wineries, farm stands, horseback riding, outlet shopping, beach, splash splash water park, golfing, & More. Just an hour and 15 minutes to NYC. LAND IS LEASED at APPROX $8,335 annually AND NOT INCLUDED IN SALE. Community is seasonal only open April 15-October 15. Cash only sales.

46 Anchor Path, Baiting Hollow

$675,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1055561 MLS

Take a look at this condo in The Knolls of Fox Hill, in Baiting Hollow, and you'll be in for a treat. As you approach the front door, the salty sea air conjures memories of those long days spent at the beach as a kid. You'll notice a welcoming covered balcony that overlooks the Sound and those jaw-dropping North Fork sunsets. Once inside, the word "swanky" might come to mind. The flow between the living room, dining area and kitchen; seamless. The tasteful design choices will have you feeling warm and luxurious. The Kitchen, is just your style with high end appliances. Not only are the design choices so rich, but there's plenty of storage too. Wait until you see the bathrooms - both gorgeous! The primary will have you saying "wow", and both bedrooms have access to a rear balcony which is super cool. As if the vibe and surroundings aren't enough, you'll have a place for that fancy new car of yours in the attached 1.5 car garage, plus there's an additional really big storage area. On top of all of that, are the amenities: tennis, pickleball, bocci, a huge swimming pool, a clubhouse, fitness center, access to the beach and you're so close to a nearby golf course. Literally, you're going to feel like you're living at a resort!

3103 Bluffs Drive S, Baiting Hollow

$785,999

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1056644 MLS

Welcome home.This charming, tranquil home set on approximately 1.05 acres in desirable Baiting Hollow. Offering 3 bedrooms, two full bathrooms. This property combines comfortable living with the privacy and space of a generous lot. Full finished basement with private office and tons of storage. This is a must see home. The home's practical layout provides flexibility for everyday living, entertaining, or working from home. Outside, the expansive grounds offer plenty of room for recreation, gardening, and creating your ideal outdoor retreat. Conveniently situated near the North Fork's beaches, vineyards, farms, golf courses, shopping, and dining, this home presents an excellent opportunity to enjoy the relaxed East End lifestyle.

71 Triangle Lane, Baiting Hollow

$649,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1053153 MLS

This premium top-floor condo, will WOW you! The open concept, vaulted ceilings and skylights scream luxury. The view is spectacular. Inside, an updated kitchen with gorgeous appliances, hardwood flooring throughout, a cozy fireplace, renovated bathrooms and you'll love the well-appointed laundry room. Both the spacious primary bedroom and guest bedroom have access to a rear balcony. Large baseboard & crown molding, California closets, tasteful light fixtures, room darkening drapes & pull down attic stairs too. Another amazing feature is the garage and additional storage space. Last but not least are the community amenities: a huge swimming pool, multiple tennis and pickelball courts, bocce, playground, club house, fitness center and access to the beach. You've got to see it for yourself and make this home your reality!

3104 Bluffs Drive S, Baiting Hollow

$234,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1052527 MLS

This Cottage Will Impress you from start to finish. Located in Desirable Seasonally Only community of Woodcliff Park open April 15-October 15. Land is Leased at approx $8,335 annually. Tastefully decorated throughout coupled with the fact that this particular cottage is set up like a Duplex with 2 bedrooms up with a kitchen, living room, and full bath & 2 bedrooms down also with a living room, bathroom, & kitchen lends to numerous possibilities. Upstairs has Vaulted ceilings, with lots of natural sunlight, Woodburning Stove, Spacious kitchen W/Sliders to Deck. The Entire cottage is move in condition & ready to enjoy. This Snowbird or Vacation home is ideal to share ownership with a relative or friend or rent our lower level to offset your land lease. Numerous attractions include: Beach, Golfing, Outlet shopping, Horseback riding, Splish Splash water park, Aquarium, & More!! Just 1 hour and 15 minutes to NYC. Hampton Jitney just 5 Minutes from park. The Ideal Getaway.

5 Surfway S, Baiting Hollow

$379,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1050270 MLS

You Dreamed it & Now you can Own It! Note: Cottage was 2 Bedrooms and is currently set up as an Open Floor Plan Studio Style. Set high on a bluff in Woodcliff Park, this fully furnished cottage offers unobstructed water views and a relaxed seasonal retreat by the shore. The beachfront community is open from April 15 through October 15, making this an inviting destination for spring, summer, and early fall escapes. Inside, 486 square feet are arranged with efficiency and character. A vaulted ceiling with exposed wood beams creates an airy sense of space, while oak floors add warmth throughout. The kitchen was updated in 2014, and a 12,000 Btu air conditioner provides welcome comfort on hot summer days. A new 40-gallon hot water heater was installed in 2024. Updated wood siding and a roof, both approximately four years old, add practical value. Outdoor living takes center stage on the entertainer’s deck, where expansive views provide a memorable backdrop for morning coffee, casual meals, and evening gatherings. A patio offers another place to relax, while the full unfinished basement supplies useful storage for bicycles, beach equipment, and seasonal belongings. Surrounding area offers wineries, farm stands, golf, horseback riding, Splish Splash Water Park, and outlet shopping. Riverhead train station is nearby, and New York City is approximately one hour and 15 minutes away. Land is leased at $13,012 annually, and this is a cash-only purchase. Make this bluffside cottage your seasonal getaway—schedule a private tour today....

36 Beach Hill Drive, Baiting Hollow

$159,990

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1050271 MLS

The Seaglass Cottage is One of a Kind! This charming home away from home offers a quaint picket fenced in front yard, living room with vaulted ceiling and fireplace, Vinyl wood-like flooring, Eik, Updated bathroom with subway tile, 2 bedrooms, a shed finished into additional recreational space with your choice on how to use it, Entertainers deck, outside shower, washer/dryer, shed & More! Fully Furnished and decorated to charm your fussiest buyer. Nestled in seasonal Beachfront community of Woodcliff Park open April 15-October 15. Cash Only sale. Land is leased and not included in the sale. Local Attractions include: Wineries, Splash Splash, Atlantis Aquarium, Golfing, Fishing or Sunbathing at beach, Horseback Riding, Farm Stands, & More!! Just an hour & 15 minutes from NYC.

30 Neptune Place, Baiting Hollow

$714,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1044389 MLS

Spacious 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Colonial offering approximately 2,265 square feet of living space on a generous half-acre lot. A bright, welcoming floor plan offers abundant natural light and plenty of room to gather and entertain. The main level features a formal dining room, spacious living room with fireplace, large kitchen with an abundance of cabinetry and storage, convenient half bath, and direct access to the attached two-car garage. Upstairs are three well-proportioned bedrooms with a full hall bath, along with a spacious primary bedroom featuring a private en-suite bath. A large unfinished basement provides excellent additional storage and possibilities for future use. Outside, enjoy a large, open backyard with plenty of space for entertaining and recreation. Set in a quiet residential neighborhood with convenient access to Riverhead and the North Fork's popular vineyards, farm stands, restaurants and local attractions. Property is being sold as-is.

63 Nicholas Way, Baiting Hollow

401 Fox Hill Drive Unit #401, Baiting Hollow

$649,999

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1042397 MLS

EXCEPTIONAL VALUE!! FULLY FURNISHED 100% turnkey North Fork Wine Trail escape that gets you waterfront views of Long Island Sound with the closest access to private beach. This corner end unit offers expanded outdoor living space in the serenity of the quietest building in the community, peacefully distanced from catering hall events. This dog-friendly neighborhood welcomes up to 2 dogs, while you enjoy private pool, tennis, pickleball, gym, and playground amenities. Styled in North Fork-chic and ready to use Day 1. Private showings only. Full inclusion list provided at showing. Live the North Fork lifestyle now.

401 Fox Hill Drive Unit #401, Baiting Hollow

$159,990

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1042120 MLS

Ever Dreamed of Owning a Vacation Home on Long Island? Now you can. This Charming Well Maintained Cottage offers Numerous Recent Updates Including Updated Electric, Plumbing, Washer & Dryer in New Cedar Enclosure, Custom Cedar Outdoor Shower With Sleek Black Stone Accents & Fixtures, New Retaining Walls, Parking for 2-3 Vehicles, Ample Outdoor Entertaining Area on your Covered Porch. Inside You will find Clean White Cabinetry, & an Open & Airy Living Space along with Two Bedrooms & a Full Bath w/Shower Stall. Private Beach access is just around the corner. Just an hour & 15 minutes from the NYC & With no shortage of Local Activities you will not be disappointed in with this Location. Located inside Desirable Seasonal Beachfront Community of Woodcliff park open April 15 -October 15. Cash Sales Only. Land is leased and not included in sale. Local attractions include: Beach, Golfing, Horseback Riding, Farm Stands, Wineries, Splash Splash Water Park, Aquarium, Outlet Shopping, & More!

15 Cottage Road, Baiting Hollow

$799,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1037778 MLS

Moments from the Long Island Sound, this beautifully renovated Baiting Hollow Colonial offers the best of North Fork living. Spanning 2,378 sq. ft., the 4-bedroom, 3-bath residence features an open kitchen with quartz countertops and stainless steel appliances, hardwood floors, a fireplace, and a spacious primary suite with an en-suite bath and walk-in closet. The first level includes a formal dining room, full guest bath, and attached two-car garage, while the second level offers four bedrooms and two full baths. An unfinished basement provides additional space with flexibility for future use. Set on nearly a third of an acre with direct access to Edwards Beach, the property is well positioned near quality North Fork entertainment and local attractions.

1871 Edwards Avenue, Baiting Hollow

$399,990

6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1037783 MLS

SEASONAL ONLY COMMUNITY OPEN APRIL 15-OCTOBER 15. Picture waking to shimmering water views, coffee in hand, on a covered deck perched inside the beachfront community of Woodcliff Park. This six-bedroom, three-bath duplex delivers rare flexibility, comfort, and a genuinely smart financial angle all in one breezy North Fork package. Land lease for 2026 is $9,578.77 The clever layout features three bedrooms and a full bath upstairs, plus three more bedrooms and another full bath below. Two complete kitchens one of which comes with Viking appliances mean everyone gets their own space, while soaring vaulted ceilings add drama overhead. A built-in fish tank brings unexpected personality, and a Viking grill turns backyard cooking into a proper event. Here's the part your accountant will love: renting the lower level covers all annual expenses. Translation? Your upper retreat essentially pays for itself, making this an ideal snowbird escape or carefree vacation getaway. Outdoor living shines with a wraparound blend of covered deck, open deck, and welcoming porch, plus a handy garage for beach gear and toys. Adventure sits right outside the community. Sip local pours at Baiting Hollow Farm Vineyard, dine at the charming Cooperage Inn, splash the day away at Splish Splash Water Park, or chase bargains at Tanger Outlets Riverhead. Please note: land is leased and this is a cash-only opportunity. Ready to trade ordinary summers for something unforgettable? Schedule your private showing before the season slips away.

5 Woodcliff Trail, Baiting Hollow

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.