Sayville Real Estate

Welcome to Sayville, a charming community nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. Renowned for its picturesque landscapes and vibrant local culture, Sayville is not just a delightful place to live but also home to an exceptional school district that prioritizes educational excellence.

The Sayville School District is celebrated for its commitment to fostering a nurturing and stimulating environment for students. With a focus on academic achievement, the district offers a comprehensive curriculum that caters to diverse learning styles and interests. From its highly qualified teachers to its state-of-the-art facilities, Sayville schools provide students with the resources they need to thrive.

Parents can rest assured knowing that Sayville High School, along with its elementary and middle schools, consistently ranks among the top in the state. The district emphasizes not only academic rigor but also the importance of extracurricular activities, encouraging students to explore their passions, whether in the arts, athletics, or community service.

In addition to its strong academic programs, Sayville is known for its close-knit community atmosphere. Families appreciate the small-town feel, where neighbors know each other and local events foster a sense of belonging. The district also values parental involvement, making it easy for families to engage in their children’s education through various programs and initiatives.

Choosing Sayville means investing in a bright future for your family, where quality education meets a supportive community. Discover the charm of Sayville and see why so many families are proud to call this remarkable town home!

Newest Listings in Sayville

$679,000

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1062818 MLS

A Rare Find in Pinewood Gardens! Discover the charm and elegance of this mint-condition corner-unit townhouse in the desirable Pinewood Gardens 55+ community in Sayville. Offering 2 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, this beautifully maintained home features an inviting open floor plan and the convenience of a first-floor primary suite. Beautiful hardwood flooring and elegant wainscoting add warmth and character throughout. The living room makes a striking impression with its soaring cathedral ceiling, gas fireplace, and sliding glass doors leading to a private patio with an electric awning—perfect for outdoor relaxation. The well-appointed kitchen features maple cabinetry, stunning granite countertops, abundant counter space, a breakfast bar, and stainless steel appliances. A lovely dining room provides an ideal setting for entertaining. The first-floor primary suite offers three double closets and a private bath with an oversized shower and linen closet. A powder room and convenient laundry area complete the first floor. Upstairs, a second bedroom and full bath and an expansive den/family room provide versatile space for guests, a home office, or a comfortable retreat. A charming window seat with built-in storage, along with generous closets throughout, adds to the home's exceptional storage options. Radiant heat adds comfort to the first floor and second-floor bathroom. Enjoy outdoor dining on the patio, complete with a natural gas hookup for your barbecue—no propane tank required! Additional features include a one-car garage, newly paved driveway, and ample guest parking nearby. Ideally located in the quaint and vibrant town of Sayville, Pinewood Gardens offers convenient access to wonderful shopping, a variety of dining options, a lovely beach, and the ferries to Fire Island. Enjoy comfortable, low-maintenance living in this exceptional home!

32 Coral Lane, Sayville

$599,000

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1057980 MLS

Welcome to 1 Grand Canyon Ct, where bright interiors, generous proportions and inviting outdoor spaces fuse together beautifully. This 2-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom townhouse condo is exceptionally well kept, with thoughtful details throughout. The front entry sets the tone with handsome stonework and a welcoming approach. Inside, beautiful hardwood floors and abundant natural light lend the main level a warm, polished feel. The living room’s high ceilings add an extra dimension of space, while the kitchen is both beautiful and highly functional with stone countertops, complementary tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, undermount sink, plentiful cabinetry and generous counter space. The open flow connects the kitchen to the formal dining room, incorporating a bar-height counter that makes entertaining feel natural and keeps the conversation moving easily between rooms. Both bedrooms are bright and spacious, with the primary suite offering a walk-in closet complete with built-in organizer and an ensuite bath with a glass shower and separate tub. The finished basement offers flexible additional living space, while outside, the deck and interlocking brick patio create an appealing extension of the home. Open the sliding doors, settle into the afternoon sun and enjoy a good book - or invite friends over and let the space do the rest. With an attached garage, ample driveway parking and beautifully maintained grounds, this is a home that balances comfort, style and practicality -with ease!

1 Grand Canyon Court, Bohemia

$1,750,000

1050283 MLS

229 Railroad Avenue, Sayville, NY Fully Rented Medical Office Investment | 4,697 SF | 0.49 Acres For the first time ever, 229 Railroad Avenue is being offered for purchase — a rare opportunity to acquire a fully rented, medical-grade commercial building in the heart of Sayville. This impeccably maintained asset provides immediate, stable income and represents a premier investment in one of Long Island’s most desirable downtown corridors. Situated on 0.49 acres, the 4,697-square-foot, single-level building is professionally designed and currently configured with five private medical/professional suites, each with its own reception area, operator rooms, and private bathrooms. All suites are connected by a shared central hallway, allowing independent operation while maintaining efficient building flow. The property offers approximately 25 on-site parking spaces, a highly valuable amenity for medical and professional tenants, and is conveniently located within walking distance of both the Sayville Train Station and Main Street. Property Highlights - Fully rented investment property with immediate cash flow - 4,697 SF medical/professional office building - Situated on 0.49 acres - Five private suites with reception areas, operator rooms, and bathrooms - Approximately 25 dedicated parking spots - Medical-grade infrastructure throughout - Flexible layout suitable for medical, healthcare, or professional office use - Walking distance to Sayville Train Station and downtown amenities - First-time offering This exceptionally maintained building combines strong in-place tenancy, ample parking, specialized medical buildout, and a prime Sayville location. Opportunities to acquire a medical office investment of this caliber are exceedingly rare. Financials, rent roll, and pricing available upon request. Schedule your private tour today.

229 Railroad Avenue, Sayville

$749,999

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1062286 MLS

Great investment opportunity in a desirable neighborhood. This property is in livable condition but features a spacious layout with massive potential for flipping or customizing. Contract vendee sale. Property is being sold completely "as-is". Cash offers preferred.

289 Sayville Boulevard, Sayville

$719,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1059995 MLS

Set on a quiet dead-end street in West Sayville, this inviting three-bedroom, two-bath ranch welcomes you with a covered front porch. Inside, hardwood floors and an open floor plan connect the living room, dining area, and updated kitchen. Cathedral ceilings add an airy feel to this true cook’s kitchen, featuring double ovens, a separate cooktop, and generous counter space and storage. The primary bedroom offers a walk-in closet and a recently renovated private bathroom, while a second full bathroom with a bathtub serves the two additional bedrooms. The basement includes a recreation area, laundry center, and a separate storage and utility room. Outside, an expansive deck and semi in-ground swimming pool create a welcoming setting for summer gatherings. A pergola offers a shaded spot to relax on warm days, while surrounding landscaping provides privacy. Located in the Sayville School District, with Cherry Avenue Elementary School. Don't miss this gem!

49 Muriel Place, West Sayville

$1,199,900

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1053236 MLS

Desirable South Sayville Location! This charming Traditional Colonial offers classic character, and a wonderful layout. Featuring 5 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, the home welcomes you through an entry foyer leading to a spacious formal living room filled with natural light and a formal dining room perfect for gatherings. The eat-in kitchen flows into a comfortable den with a brick wood-burning fireplace and access to the beautiful backyard bluestone patio. Gleaming oak flooring throughout adds warmth and character. The first floor also includes a laundry room, home office or potential 6th bedroom, and a half bath. Upstairs, the spacious primary ensuite features a walk-in closet and full bath, along with an adjoining room currently used as a sitting area. Four additional generously sized bedrooms all with walk-in closets and another full bath complete the second floor. Enjoy all that Sayville has to offer, just a short distance from the village, marinas, ferries, LIRR, restaurants, and shopping.

104 Benson Avenue, Sayville

$799,999

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1059645 MLS

Welcome to 36 George St. in Sayville, custom built in 1986 for the family who still owns it today. This spacious four bedroom, three and a half bath Colonial offers comfort and flexible living. The distinctive layout includes two primary en suites, one on the first floor and another on the second. Inside you will find a full kitchen and an inviting living room with a fireplace. Step outside to a covered rear porch overlooking the heated inground saltwater pool, offering space for relaxing and entertaining. Additional highlights include fully paid-off solar panels and a full basement with abundant space. Offered for sale by the original family, this home is ready for its next chapter.

36 George Street, Sayville

$849,999

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1053591 MLS

Sayville New Listing — Space, Flexibility & Endless Possibilities This expansive Sayville home offers remarkable square footage, flexible living areas, and unique features that create opportunities for multi-generational living, work-from-home setups, or simply room to grow. Starting at the rear of the home, you’ll find a bonus room with a full bathroom and a separate entrance to the backyard, opening the door to unlimited possibilities — guest suite, studio, private office, or recreation space. A trap door in the ceiling with a fire ladder provides optional access if a future owner chooses to open the space to the upstairs. The beautifully updated kitchen features a gas stove, a double oven large enough to accommodate a full turkey, rich oak-cherry finish cabinetry with strawberry-style knobs, a French door refrigerator with a catering drawer, and a classic farm sink. Adjacent to the kitchen is a 10×10 work room with shelving — ideal for storage, hobbies, or pantry expansion. A huge 20 x 10 screened-in porch, creating seamless indoor-outdoor living. The main level also includes a formal dining room and a spacious living room with built-ins, perfect for gatherings. Upstairs, you’ll find four bedrooms and a humongous walk-in closet that leads to a bonus room — a standout feature offering multi-generational potential, a private office, guest suite, or creative studio. Inside the walk-in closet is additional storage with a built-in workstation, originally designed during the COVID era and is still incredibly useful today. The fully finished attic, currently used as a playroom, adds even more flexible square footage and expansive possibilities for future use.

84 Tower Street, Sayville

$749,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1055909 MLS

Welcome to 19 Cherry Avenue, West Sayville! This charming (3) Bedroom (3) Full Bath home offers a wonderful blend of comfort, character, and functionality. Featuring beautiful Hardwood Floors, a cozy WOOD-BURNING FIREPLACE, natural gas, and gas radiator heating. The main level offers two bedrooms, a full bathroom, an Eat- In Kitchen with granite countertops, and a convenient washer and dryer. Upstairs, you’ll find a spacious third bedroom, full bathroom, attic access, and a versatile Loft Area! The home also features window-unit AC throughout and a convenient side mudroom. The full-finished lower level has a separate entrance and additional storage with immense privacy and potential for extended family offering plenty of flexible space suitable for multiple options!! Outside, enjoy a lovely blank canvass equipped with a detached One Car Garage - in-ground sprinklers with a WiFi system, new cesspool system and a recently completed walkway, and patio. Close to all major shops, dining, convenience, and much more including but not limited to the West Sayville Country club, multiple marinas and everything that comes with Main Street USA living! Make this one yours! A true “move in ready” beauty! LOW TAXES w/ Basic STAR!

19 Cherry Avenue, West Sayville

$2,100,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1054538 MLS

Stunning Custom 2-Story Bay-View Home with Heated Pool & Roof Deck. Built in 2014, this Open-concept floor plan with uninterrupted views of the pool and deck. Spacious living area centered around a gas fireplace, a beautiful cook’s kitchen with large two-tiered island featuring a wine cooler adjacent to a dining area with seating for 8. One equal-sized office/bedroom with full bath provides flexibility and completes the first floor. Thoughtfully designed with shares in mind, every bedroom/office suite is identical in size and furnished with two twin beds that easily convert to king-size beds. Second Floor, custom open staircase leads to three equally sized bedrooms, each with its own ensuite bathroom featuring a large shower. Common front balcony with bay views and power makes for an ideal remote workstation location. Convenient laundry area, linen closet, and lockable owners’ closet. Enjoy year-round comfort with fully air-conditioned and heated spaces via individual Mitsubishi two-zone split systems with dedicated controls in each bedroom/office and common areas, plus ceiling fans in all bedrooms. Enjoy a private landscaped yard centered on a heated pool (electric heat-pump heater) with full-length steps and lighting. Expansive mahogany pool deck offers outdoor dining for 8, lounge chairs, multiple umbrellas, built-in bench seating, BBQ area, and a wrap-around deck leading to an outdoor shower. A custom 5-zone audio system delivers sound throughout the living areas with outdoor speakers for the pool and roof deck areas. Large private roof deck accessed from the second floor, complete with lounge area, chairs & table, and sweeping bay views This listing offers a rare combination of a desirable rental history, premium location, quality construction, modern comfort, flexible sleeping arrangements and exceptional outdoor living. This listing has a strong rental history with multi-year shares and limited turnover. Beautifully maintained, quality-constructed, energy-rated, winterized home offers a flexible layout, quality finishes, and exceptional indoor-outdoor living, located close to shopping, water taxi’s and Tea!

221 Bay Walk, Fire Island Pines

$629,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1053441 MLS

INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY IN SAYVILLE! Bring your vision to 2 Willett Avenue, a 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath Colonial Revival offering a compelling value-add opportunity in a highly desirable Sayville location. Offered as-is, this property offers an opportunity for a buyer, investor, or contractor looking to renovate, modernize, and create value. The home retains the character that makes a Colonial Revival special, with a welcoming sunroom, hardwood floors, and classic architectural details throughout. The traditional layout provides a strong foundation for renovation, while the fully finished basement with a private outside entrance adds valuable flexibility and additional usable space. Whether you're an investor searching for your next renovation project, a contractor looking for a property to transform, or a buyer who sees the potential in putting their own stamp on a home, 2 Willett Avenue offers the opportunity to take an existing property and make it your own.? And then there's the location, close to downtown Sayville, restaurants, shopping, transportation, and the many amenities that make the South Shore so desirable. The opportunity is here. The work is yours. Bring your contractor, your plans, and your vision to 2 Willett Avenue.

2 Willett Avenue, Sayville

$628,990

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1051969 MLS

Welcome to this charming 2-bedroom home offering a spacious and unique layout. The entire second floor is dedicated to the primary bedroom, creating a private retreat, the room is 362 sq. ft. The main level features an eat-in kitchen, inviting living room, formal dining room, additional bedroom, and full bath.Andersen Front Storm Door. Andersen Sliding Glass Doors open to a deck overlooking an impressive fenced yard approximately 175 feet deep, providing plenty of space for outdoor entertaining, gardening, or relaxing. Additional features include a full Utility Basement and Detached Garage with Electric and the rear of the Garage offers storage for items. The windows have been replaced, the gutters have been redone, and the fence was done. Conveniently located near the main street, shopping, dining, and the train station for easy commuting. A wonderful home with great indoor and outdoor space! Photos coming soon!! Taxes Do Not Reflect Star. True Taxes Under 10 Thousand Dollars Before Star Rebate!!

7 Eastover Road, Sayville

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.