Wheatley Heights Real Estate

Welcome to Wheatley Heights, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. This charming community offers a unique blend of suburban tranquility and urban convenience, making it an ideal place for families and individuals alike.

Wheatley Heights boasts a rich history and a warm, welcoming atmosphere, characterized by tree-lined streets and well-kept homes. The area is known for its strong sense of community, where neighbors become friends and local events bring everyone together. With a population that values both diversity and inclusivity, you’ll find a vibrant tapestry of cultures that enriches the community’s character.

Nature enthusiasts will appreciate the proximity to parks and recreational areas, perfect for leisurely strolls, picnics, or weekend sports. The nearby parks, such as the expansive Belmont Lake State Park, offer a variety of outdoor activities, from hiking trails to fishing spots, ensuring that residents can enjoy the beauty of nature right at their doorstep.

Convenience is key in Wheatley Heights, with easy access to major highways and public transportation, making commutes to New York City and other parts of Long Island a breeze. The local shopping centers and dining options cater to all tastes, providing everything from quaint cafes to diverse restaurants.

Whether you’re seeking a peaceful place to raise a family or a vibrant community to call home, Wheatley Heights is a wonderful choice. Discover the charm and allure of this delightful neighborhood, where every corner holds the promise of a fulfilling lifestyle. Welcome home!

Newest Listings in Wheatley Heights

175 Main Avenue Unit #149, Wheatley Heights

$249,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1061861 MLS

Introducing 175 Main Ave #149 — Step into this inviting unit featuring a beautifully updated kitchen with Cherrywood cabinets, an electric stove, stainless steel appliances, brand new microwave, highats, central air, updated bathroom & much more. Light floors flow through the open-concept dining and living area, creating a bright and welcoming space ideal for everyday living and effortless entertaining. The spacious bedroom offers abundant natural light. Additional perks include newly installed windows for enhanced comfort and efficiency. This is the One - An Absolute Must See.

175 Main Avenue Unit #149, Wheatley Heights

$499,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1060366 MLS

The best value in Wheatley Heights! Move in ready 3 bed/1 bath ranch on a quiet dead end street. Huge 8000 square foot lot. Large driveway with room for several cars or work/recreational vehicles. Conveniently located within 1/2 mile to LIRR. Landscaping photos have been enhanced by A.I.

20 Buchanan Avenue, Wheatley Heights

$350,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1056129 MLS

Charming Cottage Vibes with Endless Outdoor Potential: Detached 1-Bed Sanctuary on a Sprawling 7,500 SQFT Lot! 55 Main Avenue, Wheatley Heights, NY 11798 INTERACTIVE 3D VIRTUAL TOUR AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST! Explore every inch of this home virtually—an interactive 3D tour link is available for complete access. Why pay monthly HOA or maintenance fees when you can own your very own detached single-family sanctuary in peaceful Wheatley Heights? Tucked away on a quiet street, this cozy home offers the ultimate combination of independent living, low-maintenance comfort, and massive outdoor space. It is a dream setup for first-time buyers, downsizers, or anyone looking for a private retreat with plenty of elbow room. The Interior & Layout Cozy & Manageable Living: Offering 520 sq ft of living space plus a 330 sq ft full unfinished basement, the efficient layout maximizes every inch, making daily living and upkeeping effortless. Serene Bedroom: A comfortable primary bedroom retreat designed for restful nights and peaceful mornings. Full Bath: Centrally located, full bath serving both the bedroom and living quarters. Warm Living Spaces: Bright living and dining areas ready for your personal design touch, providing an inviting atmosphere from day one. Full Unfinished Basement: A blank-canvas full basement in untouched condition, offering a clean slate ready for your custom storage solutions, workshop setup, or creative design ideas. *Please note: While we took the liberty of offering virtually staged renovation ideas to spark your inspiration, the current condition and design of the home are in pristine, mint condition! Unmatched Outdoor Space & Expansion Potential 7,500 SQFT Private Yard: The true crown jewel of this property! Situated on an impressive 75’ x 100’ lot, your backyard options are limitless. Design the ultimate outdoor entertainment zone, plant a thriving garden, set up a fire pit, or host summer BBQs with total privacy. Room to Grow: With a footprint positioned on a spacious lot, this property holds potential for future expansion, customization, or outdoor additions (subject to local zoning approvals). Private Parking & Independence: Enjoy the convenience of private driveway parking and the total freedom of single-family ownership—no shared walls, no upstairs neighbors, and no condo boards. The Wheatley Heights Location Suburban Tranquility: Enjoy the peaceful, tree-lined residential charm of Wheatley Heights in Suffolk County. Parks & Nature: Quick access to scenic green spaces like Usdan Summer Camp for the Arts grounds, Geyser Park, and nearby hiking trails. Convenient Access: Easily connected to the Northern State Parkway, Deer Park Avenue, and nearby LIRR stations (Wyandanch and Deer Park) for straightforward travel across Long Island and into NYC.

55 Main Avenue, Wheatley Heights

$675,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1054531 MLS

Spacious High Ranch With Many Recent Updates. Possible Mother/Daughter With Proper Permits. There are 5 Bedrooms Total, Plus Additional Bonus Room, 2 Full Bathrooms, Newly Renovated Eat-in Kitchen With An Island & Open View Of Comfortable Living Room. All New Stainless Steel Appliances. Beautiful Hardwood Floors Throughout Upper Level. Lower Level Has 2 Large Bedrooms, Den, Bonus Room & An Outside Entrance. Great Home For Extended Family, With Proper Permits. Interior Freshly Painted, Cesspool Was Installed Within Last Few Years (2-3). New Blacktop Driveway And Walkways. Very Nice Plot Enclosed By PVC Fencing For Privacy. Convenient Location Walking Distance To Long Island Rail Road, Bus Stop And Shopping. Short Distance To Parks, Beaches, Highways, Schools And Most Amenities.

84 N 17th Street, Wheatley Heights

$849,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1051429 MLS

Welcome to this beautiful 5-bedroom, 3-full-bath Colonial! This spacious Colonial offers over 2,500 square feet of living space and plenty of room to make it your dream home. As you enter the foyer, you’ll appreciate the open layout and inviting oversized living room featuring a fireplace. The main level also offers a formal dining room, kitchen, and large family room with sliding doors leading to the backyard—perfect for entertaining, relaxing, and enjoying outdoor living. The second-floor features 5 bedrooms, including a spacious primary bedroom with its own full private bath and plenty of closet space. Additional features include a finished basement, large driveway, and covered front porch. With its spacious layout, generous bedroom count, and additional living space, this home offers plenty of potential to accommodate your lifestyle. Come see all that this beautiful Colonial has to offer and make it your own!

38 Waterford Drive, Wheatley Heights

$775,000

6 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1047037 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully maintained split-level home in Wheatley Heights, Possible Mother -daughter set up, located within the Half Hollow Hills School District. The upper level features gleaming hardwood floors, a bright living room, dining area, spacious eat-in kitchen with electric cooking, three bedrooms, and one full bathroom. The versatile lower level offers a comfortable den, additional kitchen, two bedrooms, and one full bathroom—providing excellent potential for a mother-daughter setup. Enjoy sitting on the back patio overlooking the enormous backyard, perfect for summer barbecues, parties, and outdoor entertaining. Additional highlights include a beautifully maintained front lawn, new boiler, new chimney, new sprinkler system, two heating zones, baseboard heating, garage, and a three-car driveway. Conveniently located near the LIRR, public transportation, shopping, dining, and major roadways. This possible mother-daughter set up is a must-see!

12 Bennington Place, Wheatley Heights

$650,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1043340 MLS

**142 N 27th Street, Wheatley Heights, NY 11798** Welcome to this well-maintained 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom home offering comfortable living spaces, thoughtful updates, and an exceptional **fully finished, modern new-construction basement** that truly sets this property apart. The main level features an inviting open kitchen, a spacious living room with high ceilings, and two skylights that fill the space with natural light. Hardwood flooring runs throughout the first floor, creating a warm and cohesive feel. Many of the home's updates were completed in 2019. Additional features include central air conditioning, baseboard heating, a 2017 oil tank, a roof approximately 10+ years old, and a 200-amp electrical service with a 50-amp subpanel. A **new boiler and hot water heater were installed in 2026**. The true standout is the home's **expansive, fully finished modern basement**, featuring impressive **approximately 11-foot ceilings** and a beautiful new-construction feel. This exceptional lower level includes a **full kitchen, full bathroom, and two huge bedrooms**, along with generous open living space. With its size, ceiling height, modern finishes, and thoughtful layout, the basement offers incredible flexibility for recreation, a home office, fitness area, hobbies, storage, creative pursuits, and more. **This is a space that truly has to be seen in person to appreciate its size, quality, and possibilities.** With its spacious main level, hardwood floors, abundant natural light, updated systems, and extraordinary finished basement, this Wheatley Heights home offers a unique combination of **comfort, functionality, modern updates, and exceptional space**. **Come see everything this special property has to offer!**

142 N 27th Street, Wheatley Heights

$899,999

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1022162 MLS

Welcome home to Wheatley Heights. Set on a half-acre lot, this 1968 colonial offers approximately 2,250 sq ft of living space in the Half Hollow Hills School District. The home has 8 rooms, including 5 bedrooms and 3.5 baths, with a flexible layout that lets you shape the space around your life. If you're thinking about an accessory living arrangement, you'll want to confirm permits and approvals with the Town of Babylon. Much of the big work has already been done. The home has a new roof, siding, windows and gutters, plus a conversion from oil to natural gas heat with 3 heating zones. The open kitchen now has brand-new appliances, and it flows easily into a formal dining room. You'll also find a pantry, generous closet and storage space, ceiling fans and washer/dryer hookups. A bay window and French-door entry greet you at the front. Downstairs, the partial, basement gives you extra storage. An attached two-car garage and driveway provide off-street parking. This is an estate sale being sold as-is, a chance for the next owner to add their own personal touches. Buyers should verify all information, including square footage, taxes and permits.

6 Stonington Circle, Wheatley Heights

$770,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 965076 MLS

Ranch-style home. This home features 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a formal dining room, an eat-in kitchen, and a 2-car garage. Centrally located to all. Don't miss this opportunity!

38 Hilltop Lane, Wheatley Heights

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.