South Setauket Real Estate

Welcome to South Setauket, a charming hamlet nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. This picturesque community, part of the Town of Brookhaven, boasts a rich history and a vibrant suburban atmosphere that makes it an ideal place to call home. With its tree-lined streets and welcoming neighborhoods, South Setauket offers residents a perfect blend of tranquility and accessibility.

One of the standout features of South Setauket is its proximity to nature. The area is surrounded by stunning parks and recreational spaces, including the expansive Setauket Harbor and the scenic trails of the Long Island Greenbelt. Whether you enjoy hiking, biking, or simply taking a leisurely stroll, the natural beauty of this region is sure to captivate you.

Families will appreciate South Setauket’s highly-rated school district, which is known for its commitment to academic excellence and a well-rounded education. The community is also home to a variety of local shops, restaurants, and cultural attractions, ensuring that residents have everything they need within reach.

For those who commute, South Setauket is conveniently located near major highways and public transportation options, making it easy to access New York City and other nearby areas. With its unique blend of suburban charm, vibrant community spirit, and easy access to urban amenities, South Setauket is more than just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Discover the warmth and beauty of South Setauket, where your dream home awaits!

Newest Listings in South Setauket

$719,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1063032 MLS

Welcome to 23 Sunflower Ridge Road, nestled within the highly desirable Three Village Green Community of South Setauket. This beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath townhome offers the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and low-maintenance living. Featuring a spacious and inviting layout, this home provides ample room for everyday living and entertaining. A two-car garage adds convenience, while the full basement offers generous storage and endless possibilities for additional flexible space. Enjoy the benefits of living in a private, gated community featuring beautifully maintained grounds and a community pool. Ideally situated in a sought-after location, this wonderful home offers an exceptional opportunity to enjoy comfort, privacy, and convenience. Welcome home!

23 Sunflower Ridge Road, South Setauket

$799,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1062462 MLS

MOVE-IN READY PERFECTION IN SOUTH SETAUKET! Meticulously updated 5-BR home on an oversized, flat corner lot in Three Village Schools with a yard ready to be your dream backyard. Unbeatable central location mins from Stony Brook Univ.(3mi), Hospital (3.7mi), Smith Haven Mall (3.2mi), & LIE Exit 62 (6.4mi). Light-filled & airy open-concept living/dining layout features gorgeous yard views and sliders to a wood patio with a pergola trellis. Main-level 5th BR/office also features patio sliders. Completely transformed interior boasts fresh paint, all-new trim, solid-core doors, all-new outlets, switches, lighting, LED high-hats, and very large closets throughout. Granite kitchen features brand-new French-door fridge & cooktop, pantry, and massive laundry. Features renovated ground floor full bath with stand-up shower, plus 4 upper BRs with refinished hardwoods and large bath with tub and separate shower. New water heater, 2-zone heat, solar panels, newer siding, roof, windows, gutters, cesspool, large driveway, & deep 1-car garage with attic storage. Don't wait—schedule your tour today before this turn-key gem is gone!

23 Dave Lane, South Setauket

$749,990

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1011802 MLS

Welcome to 10 Elk Lane, a spacious abode nestled in the vibrant community of S. Setauket, NY. This expansive residence boasts five bedrooms and three bathrooms, offering ample space for comfort and creativity. The secluded backyard provides a private haven, ideal for outdoor relaxation or entertaining. Inside, you'll discover a generously sized dining room, perfect for memorable meals and gatherings. The expansive primary bedroom, complete with a large adjoining suite, offers an inviting retreat. The home's fifth bedroom, cleverly adapted from a former garage, adds a unique touch to this versatile floor plan. While this residence is ready for you to make your own, it holds immense potential with a touch of vision and personal style. Enjoy the convenience of being centrally located, with a variety of local amenities within easy reach. This home, with its potential and location, is a gem waiting to be discovered. Note: Taxes are $14,590 without exemptions. This house is being sold as is. 10 Elk Lane is more than a house; it's a canvas for your future. Come and envision your life here.

10 Elk Lane, South Setauket

$849,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1059073 MLS

Beautifully maintained home in the Three Village School District featuring a legal accessory apartment with a private entrance, two electric meters, and gas heating. The first floor features central air conditioning, three bedrooms, an eat-in kitchen, a living room, a dining room, and a beautiful marble bathroom. The fully finished basement provides additional space for recreation and entertaining, featuring tile flooring, an egress window, an electric fireplace, and a brand-new bathroom with a separate shower area. The upstairs accessory apartment features three wall-mounted air conditioning units, a spacious bedroom, a second bedroom or home office, a bright and airy living room, and a full eat-in kitchen with a new washer and dryer. A beautifully renovated bathroom with a soaking tub and separate shower, along with ample closet space, adds comfort and convenience. Enjoy a private, fenced backyard with park-like grounds and a large custom deck off the kitchen—perfect for outdoor dining, entertaining, or simply relaxing. Conveniently located approximately a nine-minute drive from Stony Brook University and Hospital, with restaurants and shopping nearby, this home combines comfortable living, a versatile layout, and a desirable location.

4 Longbow Lane, South Setauket

$824,999

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1057730 MLS

Welcome home to 10 Marble Stone Lane, where space, comfort and opportunity come together in the desirable Strathmore Village community of South Setauket. Set on .42 acres, this spacious 5-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers approximately 2,500 square feet with a versatile layout designed for both everyday living and entertaining. Inside, you’ll find wood flooring throughout much of the home, generously sized living spaces and plenty of flexibility for today’s needs. The kitchen is appointed with stainless steel appliances and Silestone countertops, while a wood-burning stove creates a warm and inviting atmosphere during the cooler months. Enjoy the convenience of natural gas heat, central air conditioning, 200-amp electric and a seven-zone in-ground sprinkler system. The home also features an attached one-car garage, Andersen windows and LeafFilter gutter guards. Step outside to a spacious backyard with a patio and storage shed, offering plenty of room to relax, entertain or create the outdoor space you’ve been envisioning. With five bedrooms, abundant living space and a convenient South Setauket location, this home offers the space and flexibility to truly make it your own.

10 Marblestone, South Setauket

$735,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1053910 MLS

This turnkey condo in a private gated community is bright and airy, with hardwood floors that reflect natural light, vaulted ceilings, and plenty of windows. The spacious grand living room features vaulted ceilings, a wood-burning fireplace, and a picture window. The kitchen at the rear of the condo is filled with natural light, has vaulted ceilings, newer appliances, granite counter tops and opens to an over-sized, private composite deck. The first-floor primary suite boasts two walk-in closets and a large en-suite bath. Upstairs, the open concept continues with a loft, two additional bedrooms, and another full bath. The finished basement includes a den, movie theater, and office. The HOA takes care of many tasks typically associated with single-family homes, offering amenities like a community center, pool, playground, yard maintenance, snow removal, annual exterior power washing, and driveway sealing every two years. Private location yet ideally located to access main roads for ease of travel.

41 Sunflower Ridge Road, South Setauket

$769,996

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1046047 MLS

Location! Location! Sits This Beautifully Update 3/4 Bedroom 3.5 Bath Amherst Model Townhome Nestled In The Highly Sought-After Three Village Greens Gated Community In South Setauket, Within The Acclaimed Three Village School District. This Spacious Sun-Filled Home Features A Stunning Newly Renovated Kitchen With Quartz Countertops And A Farmhouse Sink, Stainless Steel Appliances, Abundant Cabinetry And A Large Center Island With Seating. The Open Floorplan Includes A Living Room With Soaring Ceilings And Fireplace, Hardwood Floors, Luxury Laminate Floors, French Doors, Hi-Hats, Custom Moldings And Paint Tastefully Finishes Flow Throughout. The Home Offers Three Updated State-Of-The-Art Baths, And The Convenience Of Second-Floor Laundry. Additional Highlights Include Central Air Conditioning, A Newer Gas Furnace, Newer Hot Water Heater, Central Cvac And A Full Finished Basement With An Egress Window, Full Bath, Den, And Wet Bar Providing Exceptional Additional Space. A 2 Car Garage Offers Ample Room For Vehicles And Additional Storage. Enjoy A Beautifully Private, Wooded Backyard With Large Deck Along With All The Amenities Three Village Greens Has To Offer, Including A Community Salt Water In-Ground Pool, Clubhouse, Fitness Center, Basketball Court And Playground. This Beautifully Updated, Move-In-Ready Townhome Won’t Last!

4 Sunflower Ridge Road, South Setauket

$679,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1039108 MLS

*THREE VILLAGE SD* Welcome to 30 Segatogue Lane, a classic Colonial-style home in desirable South Setauket, set on a spacious 0.40-acre lot with approximately 2,007 sq. ft. of living space. The home features 4 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, two levels above grade, and a FULL FINISHED BASEMENT - an appealing feature not always found in every home in the area - providing plenty of additional versatile space for everyday living, entertaining, recreation, and storage. Enjoy peace of mind with extensive infrastructural updates, including a recently replaced roof, windows, electric cooktop, hot water heater and a GAS boiler. The private, fenced backyard features an in-ground pool, providing an ideal setting for summer enjoyment and entertainment. Conveniently located near Centereach Park, shopping centers, dining, and everyday amenities, the home is zoned for the highly regarded THREE VILLAGE Central School District, one of Suffolk County’s top-rated school districts. This is a well-structured home with classic layout lines, ready for custom cosmetic upgrades to transform it into your dream home in a premier neighborhood. *Property taxes have not been grieved and may present a potential opportunity for future reduction.*

30 Segatogue Lane, South Setauket

$975,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1025708 MLS

Welcome to 22 Milburn Rd. This stunning, four-bedroom, two full baths, split-level home is move-in-ready, with over 2,220 square feet of living space, and is located in the award-winning Three Village School District. This home offers a perfect blend of comfort, style, and modern upgrades. Featuring a brand-new roof and new exterior siding, it boasts exceptional curb appeal. Inside, the entire top floor is adorned with gleaming hardwood floors, extending through the dining room, living room, kitchen, and all four bedrooms, complemented by elegant crown moulding. The kitchen is a chef’s dream with new Bosch appliances, a gas stove, and Kraftmaid custom bathroom cabinets. Additional highlights include baseboard heating, two wall-mounted A/C units, a natural gas burner, and a new electric panel with warranty. The home also offers tile flooring in the den, laminate in the basement, and wood-like porcelain tile in the laundry room and garage. Enjoy peace of mind with ADT Home Security, plantation shutters, and custom Hunter Douglas wood blinds and custom Norman Woodlore Plantation Shutters. Outdoor living is elevated with a brand-new stone-reinforced pool and new electrical box for the 22x44 heated salt-water pool, three sheds, plus a new garage door and new downstairs windows. A brand new Bosch heating and cooling system.. The beautifully landscaped "park-like" grounds include meticulously maintained trees, shrubs, species plantings, gardens, and a manicured lawn. The in-ground pool is conveniently centered on the property so that the owners can utilize the abundant acreage which extends beyond the pool. Three sheds can house pool accessories and garden tools, bicycles, and more. This home has proximity to shopping, dining, cultural venues (Staller Center), educational institutions (SUNY), hospitals, Renaissance Technologies, golf courses, tennis courts, public pools and beaches, easy access to mass transit, Port Jefferson Ferry, close to parkways and expressways, nearby houses of worship, and low taxes.

22 Milburn Road, South Setauket

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.