Setauket Homes for Sale

Welcome to Setauket, a charming hamlet nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. Rich in history and natural beauty, Setauket offers a unique blend of suburban tranquility and vibrant community life. Known for its picturesque landscapes and historic landmarks, this delightful town is a hidden gem on Long Island's North Shore.

Setauket is steeped in history, with roots tracing back to the 17th century. The area is home to several historical sites, including the Setauket Village Green and the renowned Setauket Mill, which provide a glimpse into the past and a sense of community pride. Nature enthusiasts will appreciate the scenic trails and parks, such as the nearby Frank Melville Memorial Park, perfect for leisurely strolls or picnics with family and friends.

As for homes for sale, Setauket boasts an array of stunning properties that cater to diverse lifestyles. From charming colonial-style houses with manicured lawns to modern, spacious homes with breathtaking views, there’s something for everyone. The real estate market here is thriving, offering opportunities for first-time buyers, families, and retirees alike. With excellent schools, close-knit neighborhoods, and convenient access to major roadways, Setauket is an ideal place to call home.

Whether you’re looking to settle down or invest in a property, Setauket's real estate offerings promise a perfect blend of comfort, community, and charm. Explore the homes for sale in this enchanting hamlet and discover why so many have chosen to make Setauket their forever home!

Newest Setauket Homes for Sale

$1,500,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1043169 MLS

Welcome to 59 Dyke Road, Setauket, an extraordinary 1.5-acre waterfront estate located on the water in Strongs Neck offers a once-in-a-generation opportunity to own one of the area's most unique and versatile properties. With approximately 105 feet of frontage on Little Bay and Setauket Harbor, this remarkable offering includes a charming nearly 1,400-square-foot home, a grandfathered in cottage, detached garage, boat house, two deeded docks, a private boat ramp, and an in-ground pool—creating an unparalleled setting for waterfront living. Whether you're a builder or visionary buyer looking to create a spectacular custom waterfront estate, or a downsizer seeking a peaceful retreat with unmatched boating amenities, this property offers endless possibilities. Renovate and enjoy the existing home while taking advantage of the guest cottage and exceptional outdoor features, or design and build the waterfront masterpiece you've always imagined. The expansive grounds provide ample room to bring your vision to life while still preserving the property's incredible waterfront lifestyle. Launch your boat from your own private ramp, dock multiple vessels with two deeded docks, spend afternoons by the pool, or simply relax and take in the tranquil water views from your own backyard. Opportunities offering this combination of acreage, waterfront access, boating infrastructure, and development potential are exceptionally rare. Just moments from Stony Brook Village, local shops, restaurants, Stony Brook University, and the area's renowned beaches and parks, 59 Dyke Road is more than just a property—it's an opportunity to create a legacy waterfront estate or enjoy an idyllic coastal lifestyle exactly as it is. Rarely does a property with this much potential and this many unique amenities become available. Property being sold in as-is condition, many structures are in poor condition and will need to be rehabbed or rebuilt. Don't miss your chance to make this exceptional waterfront retreat your own.

59 Dyke Road, Setauket

$1,175,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1041228 MLS

Beautifully renovated from top to bottom in 2026, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers a rare combination of modern luxury, timeless character, and a wonderfully private setting on .95 acres, tucked back on Old Field Road. The thoughtfully designed first floor features a stunning primary suite with a luxurious marble-tiled shower, a walk-in closet, and two additional closets. A dedicated laundry room with first floor laundry and mudroom create a functional entrance in the back of the house. A warm and inviting living room centered around a wood-burning fireplace with a custom mantle connects to the formal dining room and a sunroom providing an effortless connection to the outdoors and brick patio—perfect for morning coffee, casual gatherings, or entertaining. Freshly painted interiors and newly refinished beautiful hardwood floors create a timeless backdrop throughout the home. The custom kitchen features white shaker cabinetry, quartz countertops with a large island to accommodate extra seating, pot filler, farmhouse sink, a Viking gas range with custom hood, and additional Viking and KitchenAid stainless-steel appliances. Upstairs, a custom staircase leads to three bedrooms and a full bathroom. The extensive 2026 renovations include custom tilework in the kitchen and bathrooms, Kohler toilets, designer fixtures, brand-new roof over the garage with half-round gutters, new windows upstairs, new LED recessed lighting throughout, new insulation, Wi-Fi thermostat and a new efficient heating and cooling system with heat pump technology, providing peace of mind and modern comfort. Outside, the property offers an expansive lawn, mature landscaping that has been professionally designed, a circular Belgian block driveway, and a peaceful sense of privacy rarely found so close to the area’s treasured amenities. Enjoy being near the Old Field Lighthouse, Frank Melville Memorial Park, and Emma S. Clark Memorial Library, with the charm and character of Old Field and the surrounding Three Village community right at your doorstep. A truly special opportunity to own a completely renovated home in a beautiful private setting, where exceptional craftsmanship meets an enviable location.

34 Old Field Road, Setauket

$949,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1028361 MLS

Nestled on .69 acres in the coveted Strong’s Neck community, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Colonial offers a rare opportunity to create your dream home in one of the area's most sought-after waterfront neighborhoods. Featuring an in-ground pool and generous living spaces, the home is ready for your personal updates. Gaul Road is a unique enclave of just 40 homes, offering deeded access to Minasseroke Beach and coveted mooring rights for $250/ year. Enjoy an exceptional coastal lifestyle with a short stroll to the beach for paddleboarding, kayaking, swimming, and boating. Whether you're seeking a year-round residence or a special retreat, this property combines location, lifestyle, and endless potential. Taxes are being professionally grieved - estimated reduction is $6,750.

1 Gaul Road N, Setauket

$1,649,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1020376 MLS

This home is fully available and is Old Fields best priced home!!Move Right In! Gleaming Hardwood Floors, Fresh Paint, Bright. Light, Open And Airy! Priceless location on a multi million dollar cul de sac! Amazing Private 2 acre parcel with massive deck overlooking your heated Gunite in ground pool with hot tub. ! Staycation all summer long! Soaring entry foyer... Palatial primary suite with fireplace, vaulted ceilings, walk in closets and primary bath with Jacuzzi tub, dual sinks and walk in shower. Three or four additional bedrooms, Possible Nanny wing or in home office with full bath, den with fireplace and built ins overlooking the deck and pool. Bonus, an additional second story family room. Three Car Garage, Huge basement with high ceilings, ideal for finishing. In ground sprinklers, central air... All this in the desired and sought after Incorporated Village of Old Field with it's neighborly feel....Enjoy sunsets at Old Fields private Whitehall beach, take in the stunning natural beauty of Flax Pond - an Old Field hidden treasure- or enjoy a sunlight day at Old Fields Kaltenborn Commons. Near by visit Avalon Preserve, The St. James General Store, local North Shore Beaches, Kayak the Nissequogue River and the inlets and harbors of Stony Brook, walk the Greenway Trail.. Visit the Long Island Museum or the award winning Emma S. Clark Library. Enjoy an equestrian event at Old Field Farm. Take a short ride to Stony Brook Village with its shops, restaurants, museums and the Jazz Loft or the New England like harbor front Port Jefferson Village with it's ferry to New England.. Enjoy St. James's restaurant row. Regional shopping is a short car ride away. The North Shore affords you the best in health care with Stony Brook Hospital - Suffolk's only level one trauma center, St. Catherine's hospital, Mather hospital and St. Charles hospital all a short car ride away. Stony Brook University also offers an array of activities from athletic events to events and shows at the Staller and Wang Center. Take in the nationally acclaimed Stony Brook Film Festival. Hop on the LIRR into the most exciting city in the world! So much to do, so much to see...Did we mention the acclaimed Three Village Central School District. A lifetime of memories will be made in this home. It's why Old Field Village is so sought after... Take a look at the Village site.... https://oldfieldny.org/about/points-of-interest/#of_poi-2

12 N Ridge Road, Setauket

$3,599,000

6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1010353 MLS

Strongs Neck/Setauket. Attention waterfront and boat lovers! This Conscience Bay beachfront property is an unusual offering with a 6,000 sq ft elegant completely renovated home on .77 acre with salt water heated 7.5 ft deep new pool, and dock that can handle 2 boats with water at all times. Elegant entry foyer leads to dining room, den, 2 offices and elegant kitchen with Thermador appliances and over-sized center island. The main living room with dual fireplace offers the exquisite views of the Bay on 3 sides. Beyond the kitchen is a wonderful sunroom or screened lanai. The second floor offers unusual layout with newly renovated laundry room, washer/dryer and fabulous master suite with baths and solid cherry floors. All bedrooms are Master sized and terrific closet space. Easily maintained property.

18 Cedar Lane, Setauket

$8,200,000

6 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ 1004788 MLS

Custom home to be built on a stunning 2.73-acre waterfront property in the prestigious Crane’s Neck area. This exceptionally rare offering features 102 feet of private beachfront and over 5,000 square feet of custom-designed living space, expertly crafted by a respected local builder. Buyers have the unique opportunity to choose or customize a floor plan to create their ideal luxury waterfront retreat..Customize your dream home by selecting either a sophisticated contemporary design or a timeless Hamptons-style layout. Features may include soaring cathedral ceilings, exquisite custom millwork and molding, oak floors, custom kitchen and appliances and dramatic walls of glass designed to maximize natural light and showcase breathtaking waterfront views.Do not miss this exceptional opportunity to build and own your luxury waterfront estate with a private beach in the prestigious Crane’s Neck community** Schedule your private appointment with the Builder/Agent to review plans, layouts, and custom design options for this waterfront estate opportunity. Collaborate on every detail — from California contemporary or Hamptons-style architecture to designer baths, a custom chef's kitchen and dramatic walls of glass— and bring your home to life on 2.73 acres with 102 feet of private beachfront.

47 Crane Neck Road, Setauket

$1,100,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 994993 MLS

Where does one begin? For those who want it all...coastal lifestyle, nearly 180-year-old detail that cannot be replicated, a home with soul, provenance, & stories, modern comforts, a flexible floor plan, and a property of possibilities. 45 Shore Road offers it, and then some. Constructed in approximately 1848, when shipbuilders & captains dotted this loveliest of streets that meanders along the eastern shoreline of Setauket Harbor, the Hulse House stands as a testament to time and Three Village history. This residence and neighborhood must be experienced in person. Its current stewards have invested significantly: a new innovative/alternative onsite waste treatment septic system (2021), 2-zone gas heat & 2-zone central air (2016 & 2023), a 16kw Generac whole-house generator (2018), upgraded 200amp service, extensive electrical & plumbing upgrades, and smart thermostats. Structural investments include a fully rebuilt wraparound veranda with custom Tennessee Porch Company balusters (2016), a 2010 roof (primary suite portion 2024), partially rebuilt second floor bedroom, bathrooms and kitchen, and extensive grounds improvements. A bygone era carries throughout. Patina'd elements, a whimsical feel, authenticity that cannot be manufactured - from original fixtures, doors, and 9-layer moldings, to a hand-carved marble fireplace mantle & original wide-plank floors that have felt countless steps - the Hulse House is the embodiment of a time when things were built to endure. And so they have. 9' ceilings, beautifully proportioned rooms, chandeliers on ornate medallions, and period architectural windows of impressive scale define the home's character. The parlor is its heart - embossed wallpaper, original moldings, and a hand-carved 1870 marble mantle anchor a space that adapts to dining, living, or the arrangement of your choice. The adjacent living room offers nearly floor-to-ceiling windows with harbor views just across the street. The kitchen, rebuilt in 1999, blends country charm with modern convenience - an upgraded suite of appliances added in 2022, including a 5-burner double-oven gas range and a smart fridge, glass-knobbed cabinetry, delightful millwork, a morning light-filled breakfast nook, a surprisingly generous laundry room that doubles as a walk-in pantry, and access to a breakfast porch. Four true bedrooms offer generous closets for a home of this era. The main-level primary suite features a rebuilt ensuite bath, two walk-in closets, and flexibility for an adjacent (large) nursery, study, or dressing room. The second level offers increasingly better seasonal views of the harbor & original fireplace. The third bedroom, with an original oversized 3-piece window recently uncovered and four low-sill windows, delivers remarkable light & architectural character. Additional second-floor space rounds out the picture as a study, den, or potential conversion to a suite. Magical grounds: an expansive front lawn fringed by an original concrete & inlaid stone wall, pillared entry, white picket fence, & mature plantings overflowing in the most whimsical of ways. The backyard gently inclines toward an iris-fringed patio - part of a century-old squash court - and a cedar-sided carriage house with custom 2024 doors and possibilities abound, plus ample driveway space. Your days are spent harborside. Swans glide by as herons & osprey fish. Dock at Shore Road Marina (1,000'), launch your kayak or picnic - a sandy beach is just 800' away! Revel in skies painted pink & orange at sunset, & an ever-changing harborscape: lush in summer, golden in fall, frozen and vast in winter. Admire the neighborhood's architecture. Seport Deli (500') and its legendary Boone & iced tea, and beloved Elaine's Restaurant (600') are practically neighbors. Port Jefferson Village is 3 min east; world renowned Stony Brook University & Hospital, 10 min west. Zoned for Three Village schools (Setauket Elementary, Gelinas, Ward Melville HS). LOW 3V taxes - only $11,809!

45 Shore Road, Setauket

$2,375,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 960930 MLS

Rare Waterfront on Shy 4 Acres! Flax Pond Prestige! A waterfront home that shines in every season - 110' of waterfront frontage - One irreplaceable Setting! A rare North-Shore waterfront opportunity, set back from the road and positioned on the most sought-after waterfront views of Flax Pond, Crane Neck and the LI Sound with beach access! After 45 years, the sellers are ready to pass on the title of this once-in-a-lifetime waterfront estate! The home, once a cabin hunting lodge in the 20's was purchased by Mr. Walcott, a Professor of Biology from SUNY Stony Brook in the 60's. A New England native, Mr. Walcott purposely instructed the architect to design a house to appear as an older Saltbox-style home which expanded gradually over many years; hence the multiple roof levels and somewhat irregular layout. While some internal modernization has been undertaken by the present owners, the original character of this house has been respected. Updates include; French drain in basement, filters added to the well, central air conditioning system, inground sprinkler system, Generator, SS kitchen appliances, newer oil burner. The southern meadow, meanwhile, became partially forested and transformed into a scenic lawn, both home to local wildlife, while the northern lawn has reliably served as a front lawn, bird sanctuary, and a thorough and reliable protection against the sea. Bird watch, Kayak, commune with nature and enjoy the harmony of water and wilderness, experiencing the best of both worlds. A home so warm and welcoming. You'll love the sunsets over the water that take your breath away - no matter the season....Where Land, Water, & Legacy Meet!

5 Shore Drive, Setauket

$3,900,000

6 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ 909253 MLS

***Huge Price Reduction*** Magnificent Country Waterfront Estate on shy 3 acres tucked away in Strong's Neck, Setauket..1000' on Little Bay w. private dock , Privacy with rustic elegance and designed for large family with top of the line furnishings. 5 Bedrooms 6.5 baths with grand entertainment room w. large stone Frpl and soaring ceilings, beautiful custom lighting and a full bar area, The Kitchen is outfitted with Stainless appliances and large island, radiantly heated Brazilian cherry wood floors. Outdoors this Estate is designed for entertaining with an expansive decking and patios with built in BBQ station and fireplace, Pergola and In-ground pool, 4 garages 2 attached 2 detached, 6 fireplaces, private manicured level acreage with great privacy for family compound. A Rare Opportunity to combine Elegance, recreation and a Serene waterfront lifestyle.

63 Dyke Road, Setauket

$1,200,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ L3529191 MLS

Legal home office extension from converted garage. Permits still good for 600 sq ft garage to be built. Mahogany Doors and Ebony Floors And Steps, Marble Kitchen- Hand Carved Granite Fireplace In Den. Zebra Wood Cabinets. Oil (3 Zones) And Gas Heating (1 Zone), Radiantly Heated Floors On 1st Level. New CAC unit 2019, New Andersen Windows! Custom Home with Great Presentation, Great Location! Walk to duck pond, elementary school, library,and stores. Close to SUNY. This is THE most unusual home one will see! Two m/d areas . Be prepared to see more granite and marble plus mahogany trim throughout house than you have seen before. Exterior pathway all granite. Private setting! Present all reasonable offers! Motivated owner. Additional information: Appearance:Excellent,Interior Features:Guest Quarters,Marble Bath,Separate Hotwater Heater:Y

7 Old Field Road, Setauket

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.