Old Bethpage Homes for Sale

**Discover the Charm of Old Bethpage, NY**

Nestled in the heart of Nassau County, Old Bethpage is a picturesque hamlet that perfectly balances suburban tranquility with urban convenience. Known for its rich history and charming atmosphere, Old Bethpage offers residents a unique blend of character and community spirit. With its tree-lined streets, friendly neighborhoods, and a strong sense of belonging, it’s no wonder that families and professionals alike are drawn to this hidden gem.

Old Bethpage is steeped in history, most notably showcased at the Old Bethpage Village Restoration, where visitors can step back in time and experience what life was like in the 19th century. The area is also home to beautiful parks, recreational facilities, and top-rated schools, making it an ideal place for families. With easy access to major highways and the Long Island Rail Road, commuting to New York City is a breeze, ensuring that residents can enjoy the best of both worlds.

For those looking to call Old Bethpage home, the real estate market here is vibrant and diverse. Homes for sale range from charming single-family residences to modern townhouses, catering to a variety of lifestyles and budgets. Many properties boast spacious yards, updated interiors, and proximity to local amenities, providing the perfect backdrop for creating lasting memories.

Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer or looking to upgrade, Old Bethpage offers a welcoming community and a wealth of opportunities. Explore the available homes for sale today and discover why so many have chosen to make this enchanting hamlet their forever home.

Newest Old Bethpage Homes for Sale

$1,448,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1044896 MLS

This elegant 3040 sq ft Colonial in Old Bethpage, built in 2004, offers timeless design, generous proportions, and a thoughtfully designed layout ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. Featuring 4 spacious bedrooms and 3.5 baths, the home is enhanced by expansive living areas, impressive millwork, and architectural details that create warmth and character throughout. The well-appointed kitchen features gas cooking, abundant cabinetry, and breakfast area. Upstairs, all bedrooms are exceptionally spacious, highlighted by an impressive oversized primary suite offering a very high ceiling, 2 large closets and primary bathroom. The finished basement is an exceptional extension of the home, featuring high ceilings, a large recreation area, home gym, and flexible additional space with endless possibilities for entertaining, recreation, work, or relaxation. Outdoors, the landscaped backyard provides a private setting with ample space for entertaining and relaxation. A two-car garage, low taxes, and a desirable Old Bethpage location further enhance the appeal of this exceptional home. Combining quality construction, refined details, impressive living space, and everyday convenience, this is a wonderful opportunity in the Plainview-Old Bethpage community. This listing may include images that have been digitally altered, enhanced for illustrative purposes, or virtually staged. Original, unedited images are available upon request.

1 Fairway Drive, Old Bethpage

$799,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1043227 MLS

Amazing opportunity in prime Old Bethpage! This rare 1/3-acre property, ideally situated on a quiet cul-de-sac, offers an incredible opportunity to build your dream home in the highly sought-after Plainview-Old Bethpage School District. Surrounded by mature trees and natural landscaping, this unique property is ideal for buyers, builders, or investors looking to create a custom home from the ground up. Conveniently located near schools, shopping, dining, major roadways, and transportation. Existing house is currently unoccupied and is being sold strictly in AS-IS condition. No interior access. Outside viewing only. DO NOT ENTER THE PROPERTY WITHOUT PERMISSION.

6 E Park Court, Old Bethpage

$1,788,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 1036664 MLS

Welcome To This Magnificent and Timeless Newly Constructed Colonial, Built By A Masterful Builder in the Heart of Old Bethpage. This Spectacular House Blends Classic Elegance with Modern Design. An entertainer's Dream Home Offering Privacy, Serenity and Plenty of Room to Entertain indoor and Outdoor. This Beautiful Designed Home Offers Open-Concept Layout with High-End Finishes and Exceptional craftsmanship Throughout. The Main Level featuring Entry Foyer With Dramatic High Ceiling, Sun-lit Living Room, Dining Room, A Grand Designer Gourmet Kitchen with Oversized Waterfall Island, Custom Cabinetry, High End Stainless Appliances, Sun Filled Family Room With Fireplace, Guest Bedroom with Ensuite Full Bathroom, Elegant Powder Room. On the Second Level, Luxurious Primary Suite With Fireplace and Spa Like Ensuite Full Bathroom and soaking Tub, Walk-in Closet, Junior Suite With Ensuite Full Bathroom, 2 Additional Generous Size Bedrooms, Full Bathroom. In the Lower Level, Full Finished Basement with Outside Entrance, Great Space for Recreation and Play Room, Full Designer Bathroom, Dream Laundry Room with Custom Design Cabinets. Additional Features Hardwood Floors, Recess Lighting, Central Vacuum. Welcoming Front Porch, Flat Beautiful Backyard Oasis Perfect For Outdoor Summer Entertainment. Come and Experience This Incredible New Construction Home and the Unparalleled Living Experience it Offers. This listing May Include Images that Have Been Digitally Altered, Enhanced for Illustrative Purposes, or Virtually Staged. Original, Unedited Images Are Available upon Request.

8 Allison Drive, Old Bethpage

$1,395,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1022367 MLS

This move-in ready home is nestled on a pristine .23-acre lot on a tree-lined street in the Seton Hills section of Old Bethpage. Extensively renovated in 2021, this 4/5-bedroom and 3.5-bath-residence features modern amenities, premium finishes, and gleaming hardwood floors throughout. Double entry doors open into a wide foyer with a coat closet and a tastefully appointed powder room. The foyer leads to an open layout featuring a thoughtfully designed kitchen with durable quartz counters, high-end appliances and a breakfast area, plus bright and airy living and dining spaces, and a family room. The spacious master suite includes a large walk-in closet and a spa-inspired bathroom with a shower. Additional bedrooms offer generous closet space, while the renovated main bath features a quartz-topped vanity and tub. A flexible, fully finished lower-level space with double closets provides abundant storage and can also serve as a private study or guest room. The finished basement, with porcelain tile flooring, includes a wet bar and ample space for entertaining large gatherings. Outside, a lush, manicured backyard is perfect for relaxing and is fully enclosed by low-maintenance vinyl fencing. Boasting exceptional curb appeal, the exterior features meticulously landscaped grounds, a welcoming front walkway, stately decorative columns, and an oversized 2-car garage. Highlights include soaring ceilings, main-floor laundry area, fire alarm, security system, steam humidification, hydro air, upgraded 200-amp electric, 20kW generator, and 2-zone HVAC. Close to town dining and shopping plus scenic state and county parks, this residence offers easy access to major highways and the LIRR. This property is the epitome of convenience and comfort, blending a vibrant location with seamless commuting options and a move-in ready home for modern suburban living.

Old Bethpage

$1,189,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1035009 MLS

PLAINVIEW SCHOOLS....Sought-After Location! Perfectly Situated In The Desirable Restoration Area, This Beautiful Four-Bedroom Colonial Offers Light, Bright, Move-In-Ready Living. An Inviting Front Porch Welcomes You Into A Warm And Gracious Home Featuring Gleaming Hardwood Floors Throughout. The Spacious Eat-In Kitchen Offers Granite Countertops And An Abundance Of Cabinetry. The Inviting Family Room Features A Cozy Fireplace, While The Living Room Provides Plenty Of Space For Entertaining. Home Has Gas For Heat Four Generously Sized Bedrooms Include A Primary Suite With A Full Bath And Walk-In Closet. Step Outside To Your Own Spectacular, Country-Club-Style Backyard, Complete With A Heated Gunite Pool, Paved Patio, Professional landscaping, And Fully Fenced Grounds—Perfect For Entertaining, Relaxing, And Enjoying Summer Days. The basement offers Additional Living And Recreational Space, Along With Plenty Of Storage And Closets. Ideally Located Near parks, Schools, Shopping, And The LIRR. Located In School District #4

8 Lenmore Drive, Old Bethpage

$1,549,990

4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1034992 MLS

Property Lovers Delight! Main Floor starts with a Grand Entry Foyer leading you to An Open Concept Great Room with Living Room With A Fireplace, Dining Room, Sun Drenched Large Eat In Kitchen with a Huge Island ,Quarterzite Counters and BackSplash, Stainless Steel Appliances, Large Pantry powder room French Door to an Amazing Private Huge Backyard from Kitchen Second Floor features 3 Ensuite Bedrooms! All Carrera Marble Toilets are equipped with Automatic Toilets, Multi Lit Mirrors, Primary Bath has a Double Vanity Sinks, Green Standing Soaking Tub and Shower. Lower Level Features a warm cozy cozy Den, Full Bath and 4th Bedroom Perfect as a Guest or Parents Bedroom (No Stairs) and attached garage. Basement Can be made into a Movie theatre! Currently it features Has Laundry, Utilities and Lots of Storage Exit From The Kitchen or the Den to a Private Backyard with and an IG Vinly Pool, Perfect for Pool Parties or Just Relaxing on a Quiet Weeknd Afternoon In Your Own Private Retreat! Experience An Unparalleled Living Experience! .

31 Seton Court, Old Bethpage

$1,580,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1034045 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully designed 2026 New Construction home in desirable Old Bethpage with Plainview S.D., set on an impressive 71 x 100 lot with approximately 2,838 sq ft of living space. Featuring a grand two-story entry foyer, European-style double-pane windows, and wide-plank hardwood flooring, this move-in-ready residence blends elegant and modern design, modern comfort, and thoughtful functionality. The dramatic two-story entrance and big window creates an impressive first impression while welcoming an abundance of natural light. The main level features a bright and spacious living room, dining area, and a contemporary kitchen with oversized countertop with a four-seat island, perfect for everyday living and entertaining. A flexible office or guest bedroom and a full bathroom complete the first floor. Upstairs offers four generously sized bedrooms, including two ensuite bedrooms, providing exceptional comfort and privacy. Quality finishes and wide-plank hardwood flooring continue throughout the living spaces, creating a clean and sophisticated aesthetic. Additional highlights include a full basement with foam insulation, one-car attached garage, private driveway, and a generously sized backyard ideal for outdoor enjoyment and entertaining. Conveniently located near shops, restaurants, parks, schools, and just a short drive to the Bethpage LIRR station. Located within the highly desirable Plainview School District, this exceptional new construction offers the opportunity to enjoy modern living, a spacious lot, elegant architectural details, and a prime Old Bethpage location.

2 Lee Place, Old Bethpage

$1,199,999

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1031953 MLS

Expansions Galore! Welcome to this beautifully expanded split level home offering five bedrooms and three full bathrooms with exceptional space and thoughtful updates throughout. The heart of the home is the expanded and updated kitchen featuring granite countertops, a newer refrigerator, electric range, a large center island, and an open dining area that flows into the spacious living room with soaring vaulted ceilings. The first floor boasts a stunning new primary suite with a separate entrance, walk in closet, radiant heat, a gorgeous private bath, sliders leading to the patio, a laundry room, a fifth bedroom or office, an additional full bath, a cozy den, and access to the one car garage. The second level offers two additional bedrooms, a full hallway bath, and the original primary bedroom, providing flexible living arrangements for today's lifestyle. An unfinished basement offers endless possibilities for storage, recreation, or future expansion. Step outside to your oversized fenced backyard featuring a large Trex deck, stone patio, in ground sprinklers, and exceptional privacy, making it the perfect place to relax or entertain. Additional highlights include central air conditioning, 200 amp electric service, radiant heat, a newer oil tank, an alarm system, and so much more. This is a truly special home that offers comfort, style, and incredible versatility.

9 Donald Drive, Old Bethpage

$1,326,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1023654 MLS

Welcome to This Spectacular, Beautifully Updated Split-Level Residence In the Heart Of Old Bethpage, Plainview School District. Offering the Perfect Blend of Modern Elegance, Comfort, and Functionality. This Move in Ready Home, Features 4-5 Spacious Bedrooms and 3 Beautifully Updated Bathrooms Designed to Accommodate Today's Lifestyle. This Beautiful House showcases, Entry Foyer that Flows into an Inviting and Bright Living Room, Guest Bedroom/Office with Updated Bathroom. Second Level, Sun-Lit Family Room with High Ceilings, Elegant Chef Eat-In-Kitchen with Beautiful Island and Stainless Appliances and Plenty of Room for Dining, Third Level, Luxurious Primary Suite with Ensuite Full Updated Bathroom and Dream Walk in Closet. Three Additional Generous Size Bedrooms, Beautiful Updated Full Bathroom, Full Basement with Laundry Room and Utility Room. Enjoy Outdoor Living in This Private Backyard Ideal for Entertaining, Relaxing and Creating Your Own Personal Retreat. Come and Experience this Incredible home and the Unparalleled Living Experience It Offers. This listing May Include Images that Have Been Digitally Altered, Enhanced for Illustrative Purposes, or Virtually Staged. Original, Unedited Images Are Available upon Request.

12 E Park Drive, Old Bethpage

$1,150,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 990960 MLS

Tucked away on a quiet mid-block in a highly desirable, well-established neighborhood, this beautifully expanded split-level home offers a blend of timeless elegance and thoughtful modern updates. The home features sun-filled living spaces with custom moldings, built-ins, quality finishes, hardwood floors in the living area and third level where three bedrooms and a full bath are located, and dimmable high hats. The updated kitchen includes sleek countertops, custom cabinetry, and premium finishes designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The home offers four spacious bedrooms and 2.5 baths, including a renovated full bath and updated powder room. The primary en-suite provides a private retreat. The third level includes three bedrooms and a full bath. Hardwood floors are present in the living area and third level. Step outside to a private backyard with a built-in outdoor BBQ area and kegerator, ideal for entertaining. Located in Old Bethpage within the Plainview–Old Bethpage School District, close to parks, shopping, dining, and major commuter routes. Move-in ready and meticulously maintained, this home delivers the lifestyle today’s buyers are searching for comfort, style, and elevated everyday living.

14 Jane Drive, Old Bethpage

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.