E. Setauket Real Estate

Welcome to E. Setauket, a charming hamlet nestled in the heart of Suffolk County, New York. Known for its rich history and picturesque landscapes, E. Setauket offers residents a unique blend of suburban tranquility and vibrant community life. With a population of just over 14,000, this quaint town is perfect for those seeking a peaceful retreat while still being close to the hustle and bustle of nearby metropolitan areas.

E. Setauket is steeped in history, with roots tracing back to the early 17th century. The area is home to several historic sites, including the Setauket Village Green and the renowned Setauket Presbyterian Church, which stand as testaments to the town’s storied past. Nature enthusiasts will appreciate the scenic beauty of the surrounding parks and nature reserves, such as the nearby Frank Melville Memorial Park, where walking trails and serene ponds invite outdoor adventures.

Families are drawn to E. Setauket for its highly-rated school district, which is part of the Three Village Central School District, known for its commitment to academic excellence. The community is vibrant and welcoming, hosting various events throughout the year that foster neighborly bonds and celebrate local culture.

With its charming homes, beautiful landscapes, and a strong sense of community, E. Setauket is an ideal place to call home. Whether you’re looking for a cozy family residence or a peaceful retreat, this delightful hamlet offers a perfect blend of history, nature, and modern living. Discover the allure of E. Setauket and experience the warmth of a close-knit community today!

Newest Listings in E. Setauket

$699,999

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1058623 MLS

4 Stony Wood Road, East Setauket, NY — Proudly offered by its original owner, this beautiful four-bedroom Colonial was built in 1966 and is ready for its next chapter! Featuring 2.5 bathrooms and a private backyard with a pool, this home offers the perfect opportunity to create your dream home in a desirable East Setauket neighborhood. Located within the Three Village School District, the property offers tremendous potential, timeless Colonial charm, and endless possibilities to make it your own. A wonderful opportunity to bring your vision to life!

4 Stony Wood Road, E. Setauket

$499,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1062868 MLS

This is a contract vendee. Only All Cash Offers Accepted. Sold As-Is. Possible Apartment With Proper Permits. Drive by Only.

2 Gables Boulevard, E. Setauket

$749,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1061912 MLS

Welcome to this move-in-ready 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath Devon model corner-unit condo in the highly desirable gated community of The Lakes at Setauket! Step inside to discover a bright, spacious, and inviting open layout filled with natural light, featuring generous living and dining areas and a cozy wood-burning fireplace, perfect for everyday comfort and entertaining. The updated kitchen offers stainless steel appliances, elegant Cambria quartz countertops, and a functional layout. The main level also features a convenient laundry room, powder room, and access to a one-car garage. Upstairs, the spacious primary bedroom offers a walk-in closet and a beautifully renovated ensuite bath, while two additional generously sized bedrooms and a full bathroom provide plenty of comfortable living space. Step outside to your private rear patio, an ideal setting for morning coffee, outdoor dining, or simply relaxing while enjoying peaceful wooded views. Backing a magnificent 245-acre nature preserve, this desirable corner unit offers exceptional privacy and a tranquil natural backdrop. Additional highlights include natural gas heating and cooking and pull-down attic storage. Enjoy resort-style amenities including tennis and pickleball courts, two heated saltwater pools, a fitness center with saunas, clubhouse, and playground. Conveniently located near Stony Brook University and Hospital, LIRR, Port Jefferson Village and Ferry, shopping, and dining, all within the famed Three Village School District. With annual taxes of just $5,390 without STAR and monthly HOA fees of $540, this home offers an exceptional combination of space, privacy, convenience, and low-maintenance living!

208 Erik Drive, E. Setauket

$599,999

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1061317 MLS

Set on a quiet street in Poquott Village, this adorable two-bedroom cottage offers a welcoming place to call home in a waterfront community. Life here extends beyond your front door. Poquott’s village amenities include private beaches, a community dock, deep-water mooring, parks, a playground, tennis, and gardens, along with year-round community events and private security. Spend an afternoon by the water, enjoy a game of tennis, or connect with neighbors at a village gathering. Cedar shake siding lends classic character, while recent improvements include a brand new roof and boiler, a newer washer and dryer, and an updated electrical panel. Walk along Setauket Harbor on your way to Se-Port for lunch or Elaine’s for cocktails and dinner, with nearby Port Jefferson Village offering shops, dining, a farmers market, entertainment, and the ferry to New England. A cottage with character, thoughtful updates, and a setting that makes it easy to enjoy this corner of the North Shore.

11 Sharon Avenue, E. Setauket

$678,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1061463 MLS

Located in the desirable Arrowhead community and Three Village School District, this lovely hi-ranch sits on a spacious .35-acre property. Completely renovated in 2020, the home has been freshly painted, the interior stairs refinished, and refreshed by the current owners. It's move-in ready and waiting for someone new to call it home! The garage has been legally converted into additional living space in 1972, with a Certificate of Occupancy (CO) in place. A new career opportunity has prompted the owners to relocate, giving the next buyer a chance to enjoy all this home has to offer. East Setauket is a wonderful North Shore community with a rich history dating back to the 1600s, including its connection to George Washington's Culper Spy Ring during the Revolutionary War. Enjoy nearby West Meadow Beach, take a walk through Frank Melville Memorial Park, or spend an afternoon exploring the shops and restaurants in historic Stony Brook Village. Stony Brook University, the hospital, and major roadways are also just a short drive away. A great home in a beautiful area with so much to enjoy!

32 Lodge Lane, E. Setauket

$900,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1061190 MLS

Discover a home where sun-filled living spaces, distinctive character, and a remarkable backyard come together at 20 Buccaneer Lane. Set on approximately 0.52 acres with low property tax in East Setauket’s sought-after Three Village School District, this 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath residence offers approximately 2,661 square feet designed for comfortable everyday living and memorable gatherings. , the Carriage Style Arch Roof w/50 Yr warranty, A covered front porch, established landscaping, and an updated driveway create a welcoming first impression. Inside, hardwood floors throughout, rich wood trim, and Andersen windows complement the home’s warm and inviting character. The impressive 18-by-26-foot great room is a standout, featuring 10-foot ceilings, skylights, oversized windows, and glass doors that fill the space with natural light and connect it beautifully to the outdoors. Whether hosting a lively celebration or enjoying a quiet afternoon, this spacious room offers an exceptional setting. A separate family room with a brick fireplace invites cozy evenings, while the formal dining room, accented by a decorative stained-glass light fixture, brings charm to dinners and special occasions. The eat-in kitchen offers wood cabinetry, generous counter space, a tile backsplash, and a window-lined dining area where garden views make even a morning coffee feel special. Four bedrooms provide comfortable retreats, with built-in eave storage adding distinctive character to upstairs bedrooms. Step outside to a backyard made for lingering. A spacious paved patio beneath a pergola, framed by a curved brick wall, sets the scene for outdoor meals and relaxed conversation. Enjoy summer days around the in-ground pool, complete with an newly updated liner and cover, or unwind beside the expansive fish pond, home to nearly hundred koi. Mature trees and established garden beds create a lush setting with plenty to appreciate throughout the seasons. A separate 16-by-20-foot barn with electricity offers versatile space for hobbies and storage, while a 2-car garage adds everyday convenience. From mornings on the front porch to evenings by the pond, 20 Buccaneer Lane offers an inviting blend of space, character, and outdoor enjoyment. Come experience the setting and imagine making it your own.

20 Buccaneer Lane, E. Setauket

$719,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1059556 MLS

Welcome To The Desirable Setauket Gables Section Offering This Single Family Hi-Ranch That is Located On A .41 Corner Lot Of A Lovely Cul-De-Sac. The Main Level Features Eat In Kitchen, Livingroom, Dining Room W/Sliders Leading To The Deck, Main Hall Bathroom, Primary Bedroom W/Pvt Bath Along With 2 Additional Bedrooms. The Lower Level Provides A Spacious Den With Fireplace, The 4th Bedroom, Full Bath, Laundry, Utilities And Entrance To 2 Car Garage. Some Updates Include Roof, CAC, Washer/Dryer, Rear Deck Just To Name a Few. Within The Three Village School District And Conveniently Located Near Hospitals, Shopping, Restaurants, Schools, And All That Port Jefferson & Stony Brook Villages Have To Offer. Come Make This Into Your Very Own Dream Home.

1 High Hill, E. Setauket

$849,999

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1057931 MLS

A truly exceptional offering in Setauket Meadows—this stunning corner-unit Belle Terre model stands apart as one of the finest, blending privacy, elegance, and top-tier upgrades throughout. Home showcases rich hardwood floors. The living room is nothing short of spectacular. The main-level primary suite is a true showpiece, offering the ease of first-floor living with a spa-inspired full bath. Upstairs, a versatile loft overlooks the living space, complemented by a spacious second bedroom and a full bath—ideal for guests or extended living. The lower level will exceed expectations—an impressive, finished space designed for entertaining, relaxation, or a high-end home office setup. Outdoor living is just as inviting, with a private deck and patio creating the perfect backdrop for quiet mornings or evening gatherings. This is not just a home—it’s a statement. Rarely does a corner unit of this caliber, condition, and location come to market in Setauket Meadows.

33 Blair Road, E. Setauket

$949,999

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1055947 MLS

Location, location, location! Welcome to 2 Glenwater Lane, an extraordinary opportunity to own a one-acre property in historic Old Field South, where breathtaking sunsets and seasonal views of the creek and Long Island Sound create an unforgettable setting. With West Meadow Beach, Avalon Park, and Stony Brook Village nearby, this exceptional location offers access to beautiful coastal scenery, nature trails, waterfront recreation, village shops, and dining. Proximity to the LIRR, Stony Brook University, and Stony Brook University Hospital further enhances the appeal of this remarkable address. A long, private blacktop driveway leads to a distinctive expanded farm ranch offering nearly 2,600 square feet of living space, four bedrooms, two full bathrooms, a half bathroom, and a full basement. Beautiful oak floors, custom moldings, and timeless architectural details bring warmth and character throughout. The impressive great room features floor-to-ceiling windows, four skylights, and a custom stone fireplace, with an open layout flowing into a beautifully appointed kitchen featuring granite countertops, maple cabinetry, a white center island, stainless steel appliances, a shiplap ceiling, and recessed lighting. French doors open to a brick patio, offering a beautiful place to relax and enjoy the surroundings. A formal dining room provides additional entertaining space, while the formal living room showcases a second fireplace, wood floors, French doors, and extensive custom molding. A first-floor primary suite and two additional upstairs bedrooms add flexibility to the spacious layout. The true centerpiece is the setting: an expansive parcel, spectacular sunsets, seasonal water views, and access to some of the area’s most treasured coastal and village destinations. Bring your vision and capitalize on the incredible potential of this Old Field South property! The home needs TLC and is being sold strictly as-is.

2 Glenwater Lane, E. Setauket

$748,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1053133 MLS

Welcome to Welcome to 7 Sharon Avenue, a beautiful North Shore retreat in the charming Incorporated Village of Poquott. Set on a stunning, nearly half-acre property with impressive wide frontage This well-maintained home offers comfortable one-level living with updated appliances and desirable features throughout. Enjoy the convenience of a 1-car garage, fully fenced dog run, and solar panels for added energy efficiency. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the nearby waterfront, with mooring rights offering an opportunity to enjoy boating and waterfront recreation. 7 Sharon Avenue, a beautiful North Shore retreat in the charming Incorporated Village of Poquott. Set on a stunning, nearly half-acre property with impressive wide frontage, this inviting ranch makes a memorable first impression, offering a wonderful setting for outdoor entertaining, gardening, and everyday relaxation. Featuring three bedrooms and two baths, the home combines the ease of single-level living with timeless appeal. Hardwood floors, a welcoming fireplace, and a full basement complement its comfortable layout, while the expansive grounds provide a beautiful backdrop for creating your own outdoor oasis. Additional features include solar panels ! and an electric vehicle charging availability in garage. Enjoy the exceptional amenities that make Poquott such a special place to call home, including resident beach access, waterfront parks, tennis, playgrounds, community gardens, and picnic areas. A village dock, boat launch, and kayak and dinghy storage offer opportunities to embrace life on the water, with mooring opportunities subject to village permits and availability. Located within the Three Village School District, this property brings together an inviting home, stunning grounds, and the distinctive charm of a coastal village. Discover a place where a morning at the beach, an afternoon on the water, and a relaxing evening at home can all be part of everyday life. wonderful opportunity to make this inviting ranch your own in a desirable East Setauket location! in a coveted village

7 Sharon Avenue, E. Setauket

$674,999

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1055105 MLS

Welcome to 170 Thomas Lane, located in the highly desirable The Lakes community of East Setauket. This beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of comfort, style, and low-maintenance living in a fantastic North Shore location. Step inside to a welcoming two-story foyer with high-end laminate flooring and beautiful crown molding. The main level features a stylish powder room, spacious living and dining room combination, laundry room, and a beautifully renovated eat-in kitchen with granite countertops and new appliances. A newer Andersen slider with built-in shades opens to your private patio with newer pavers—perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Upstairs, a versatile loft provides additional living space, home office potential, or a cozy sitting area. The oversized primary suite is a true retreat, featuring an impressive walk-in closet plus a second closet and a spacious primary bath with an oversized soaking tub and separate shower. A generously sized second bedroom and updated hall bath complete the upper level. Additional updates and features include a new water heater, new carpeting, newer windows, updated heating system and central air, new flooring, stylish lighting, abundant closet space, and a one-car garage with a new epoxy floor. Enjoy condo living at its best with outstanding community amenities including snow removal, a clubhouse and recreation center with gym and meeting space, two pools, tennis and pickleball courts, playground, and a picturesque community pond. Even better, this home has no current assessments. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, parks, Stony Brook University, and everything the Three Village area has to offer. Move right in and enjoy beautifully updated, carefree living at The Lakes!

170 Thomas Lane, E. Setauket

$749,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1054265 MLS

Nestled toward the back of The Lakes community, this spacious 3 bedroom, 2.5 bathroom end unit home offers a desirable blend of comfort, privacy, and resort-style living. The inviting entry foyer opens to a spacious and functional first floor featuring an eat-in kitchen, convenient laundry room, and powder room. The living room is highlighted by a gas fireplace, and opens to a private patio overlooking the lake, creating a peaceful setting for relaxing or entertaining. Upstairs, the generously sized primary suite provides vaulted ceilings, a walk-in closet, and private en-suite bathroom. Down the hallway, the large second bedroom comfortably accommodates a king-size bed, while the third bedroom is well suited for a queen-size bed. A second full bathroom with a soaking tub completes the upper level. Additional features include an attached one car garage and private driveway, providing both convenience and ample parking. The Lakes is a gated community offering an impressive array of amenities, including beautifully landscaped grounds, a clubhouse, fitness center, saunas, saltwater heated pools, playground, and tennis and pickleball courts. Ideally located near hospitals, shopping, beaches, colleges, major highways, and train stations, the community also offers the benefit of being zoned for the highly regarded Three Village Central School District. With its spacious interior, lake facing outdoor space, private garage and driveway, and extensive community amenities, this home offers an exceptional opportunity to enjoy comfortable living in a serene, resort-style setting.

317 Erik Drive, East Setauket

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.